A++ #AudioBookReview: Miss Wolcott’s Ghost by Louise Penny

A++ #AudioBookReview: Miss Wolcott’s Ghost by Louise PennyMiss Wolcott's Ghost (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, #21) by Louise Penny
Narrator: Alfred Molina
Format: audiobook, eARC
Source: publisher, supplied by publisher via Libro.fm
Formats available: hardcover, large print, paperback, ebook, audiobook
Genres: crime thriller, mystery, suspense, thriller
Series: Chief Inspector Armand Gamache #21
Pages: 416
Length: 13 hours and 42 minutes
Published by Macmillan Audio, Minotaur Books on October 20, 2026
Purchasing Info: Author's Website, Publisher's Website, Amazon, Barnes & Noble, Kobo, Bookshop.org, Better World Books
Goodreads

Armand Gamache returns!
“There’s a body in Lost Nation.”
“Where?” demands Armand as he scribbles on the pad by his bed.
But the line goes dead before Chief Inspector Gamache can question the caller.
The head of homicide for the Sûreté du Québec has no idea where Lost Nation is, or who woke him in the small hours of the morning at his home in Three Pines. What he does know is that the man was terrified.
And so Armand is thrust out of a deep sleep and into the surrounding forests in search of the mythical Lost Nation. And a body.
When he and his team of Jean-Guy Beauvoir and Isabelle Lacoste find both, the situation only grows more bizarre. The unidentified dead man appears to be from an era more than a century old. He’s lying in a long-abandoned cemetery, on top of a grave with a date, but no name.
Adding to the mystery, the early morning call appears to have come from Gamache’s friend and neighbor, Clara Morrow. While she denies any knowledge of it, it becomes clear there is some connection between her, the Morrow family, and Lost Nation.
Soon, Gamache and his team are faced with tracking down not just the legend of Lost Nation, but a lost ship, lost documents belong to an eccentric Victorian botanist, , and a mysterious plant not seen in a century, that might save, or take, countless lives.
As the murder investigation deepens, nightmarish spectres from the past begin to haunt the Sûreté officers, only heightened by the appearance of one of Gamache’s former and now disgraced proteges, with whom he must form an uneasy alliance.
As the ghosts begin to gather, Gamache, Beauvoir, and Lacoste, with the help of Reine-Marie, Clara, and the other villagers of Three Pines, realize that the body on the grave is far from the only death. To solve the crime and avert catastrophe they must look to rancid secrets and old lies no longer dead and buried.

My Review:

“There’s a body in Lost Nation,” according to the caller who has woken Chief Inspector Armand Gamache in the middle of the night. Gamache thinks the voice is a bit familiar, but the location – not at all. Which doesn’t mean he doesn’t have to find it. As the Chief of the Homicide Division of the Sûreté du Québec, it’s Gamache’s job to find it. To find the body, and investigate how it got there and more importantly, how the person who once inhabited that body died.

The story is already a quest when it begins. First Gamache has to locate someone who knows where this “Lost Nation” is. Then he needs a guide to get there – because it definitely isn’t on any map. Once he’s there and confirms that yes, there is a dead body and the circumstances of that death do indeed look suspicious, the puzzle gets bigger, not smaller. The scope gets wider, not narrower.

The body has been exposed for months, but it’s also practically buried under a tall, thorny plant that no one has ever seen before. It’s on top of a grave in a cemetery so old the stones have nearly worn away, except for that one grave. Which has a date on it but no name.

RMS Empress of Ireland

Not one of these things is like any of the others, and together they make the situation more complicated, not less. At least not until the “three fates of Three Pines”, poet Ruth Zardo, psychologist turned bookstore owner Myrna Landers, and artist Clara Morrow – along with Rosa the Duck, turn up at Lost Nation and Ruth recognizes the date. A date which should be famous but isn’t. The date of the biggest maritime disaster in Canadian history, the sinking of RMS Empress of Ireland just a couple of months before the opening salvos of the “Great War”.

But the body, the plant, and the grave are the three keys to a mystery that goes back more than a century, to a doomed ship, a cheating academic, an eccentric amateur botanist, a corrupt government official and a very large mistake about the value of scientific research conducted by those who have been denied and dismissed because they don’t possess the right credentials, the right background, or the right gender.

The roots of this murder go back to the Victorian age, and past the present into a future where Miss Wolcott’s research finally gets the credit it always deserved. Once the one murderer still left in this case to be punished gets their own just desserts.

Escape Rating A++: This was marvelous, as all of the books in this series have been. What made this one particularly fascinating was the way that it wrapped its murder plot around not one or two but THREE hidden pieces of history, and twisted them around each other like the roots of a plant – Miss Wolcott’s Ghost.

What fascinated me so much about this latest entry in this beloved, long-running series was the way that its roots got so entangled and enmeshed – and that every single thread that was teased out had to be thoroughly invested – no matter how far back in history – and resolved before the case could close.

I did adore the painstaking research on every side of this story, and that there was so much of it and that every bit was riveting. Initially, all Gamache has is the plant, because the body has no ID.

And that plant was just the tip of a very large iceberg – although that’s not what brought down the Empress of Ireland. The plant is the first mystery because it’s supposed to be extinct. Miss Wolcott, and the mysterious plant she left behind, are based on the real life eccentric amateur botanist Ellen Willmott, and her invasive plant, Miss Willmott’s Ghost.

The REAL Miss Wolcott’s (Miss Willmott’s) Ghost

The sinking of the Empress of Ireland is also a true historical event – and it’s also true that in spite of being as infamous a catastrophe as the sinking of the Titanic, it’s considerably less well known. A fact that every character in the story remarks upon as they discover the history and are themselves haunted by the events.

But there are also a long series of crimes attached to that tragedy – although the tragedy itself seems to have been just that, a tragic accident. The officials responsible for salvaging the wreck were corrupt, so the trail of their misdeeds includes a seemingly endless amount of skullduggery, including murder, covering up the original crimes and the murders, and then murdering the murderers.

So there’s an endless series of coverups going back a century, and in the middle of that there’s a dead body in the present. All the threads have to be unwoven before Gamache and his team can get at any of the truths that have been and are continuing to be hidden in this case. It’s endlessly fascinating watching them work and just as delightful to see the way they interact with each other. The seamless working relationships, the intertwined family relationships, along with the self-deprecating humor and the jokes about whether Ruth really was one of the witches in Macbeth and whether or not Gracie the dog isn’t some other species entirely.

Readers of the series love these characters, because it’s just as clear that they love each other.

One of the surprising things about this entry in the series is that, in spite of this being the 21st book, it almost manages to stand relatively alone. Many of the stories in the series, like the recent The Grey Wolf and its follow-up The Black Wolf, are tied to earlier events in Gamache’s career and/or his long-standing unfinished business in the Sûreté. This time around, the case, as multi-threaded and convoluted as it is, is confined to this one book. The part of the story that continues from previous entries is the tightly woven net of relationships that makes readers return to this series over and over.

But I think if someone wanted to start the series here, they’d have enough to work with. Not that they wouldn’t sense the depths of the relationships that they didn’t know yet, but there’s enough background to make this work as an entry point.

One final note before I finish. I listened to the first half of this book, and then switched to text because I couldn’t wait to see how all the investigations came together and well, whodunnit. Because I didn’t have a clue.

This time around the narrator is Alfred Molina, who also played Gamache in the recent TV series, Three Pines. I have mixed feelings about the reading. His voice didn’t quite match the “image” in my head, I expect Gamache’s voice to be deeper, as has been true in the case of other actors who have previously voiced the series. However, Molina is a better match, in both voice and appearance, to the image in my head of what Jean-Guy Beauvoir will look and sound like when he’s closer to Gamache’s – or for that matter Molina’s – age. Which is actually a bit of a better fit, because I’ve always thought of the series as a whole as being Beauvoir’s journey rather than Gamache’s. Gamache may be the prime mover and shaker of events – or the one most shaken – but Gamache’s character was mostly set by the time we first met him back in Still Life. Beauvoir is the character who is still becoming the person he’s going to be – and has changed and matured significantly since that original story.

All of that being said – and I recognize it’s been A LOT – Miss Wolcott’s Ghost is a book that I’ve been anticipating since I turned the final page on The Black Wolf last fall. I could not listen or read this one fast enough because there was just so much to uncover and every bit of it was compelling. If you love excellent, thoughtful mysteries with deep relationships among the characters, this series is well worth your time, whether you decide to go all the way back to the beginning in Still Life, or jump aboard here with Miss Wolcott’s Ghost. Either way, you’ll be in for a marvelous reading adventure.

2 thoughts on “A++ #AudioBookReview: Miss Wolcott’s Ghost by Louise Penny”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge