#BookReview: A Cold Night’s Dying by Simon R. Green

#BookReview: A Cold Night’s Dying by Simon R. GreenA Cold Night's Dying by Simon R. Green
Format: eARC
Source: supplied by publisher via NetGalley
Formats available: hardcover, ebook, audiobook
Genres: horror, mystery, paranormal, urban fantasy
Series: Holy Terrors #5
Pages: 192
Published by Severn House on November 3, 2026
Purchasing Info: Author's Website, Publisher's Website, Amazon, Barnes & Noble, Kobo, Bookshop.org, Better World Books
Goodreads

A witty, creeptastic paranormal locked room mystery from New York Times bestselling British fantasy author Simon R. Green. The Holy Terrors are on their honeymoon, but trouble is in pursuit.
How much good can there be in a wicked world?
A honeymoon should be all about love, pampering and relaxation – not murder! But for the Holy Terrors dream team, actress Diana Hunt and her partner in crime (solving) young bishop Alistair Kincaid, even travelling to the furthest corner of the world won’t spare them from a murder mystery.
It doesn’t help when the duo hears about the legend surrounding a supposedly malevolent monster that is said to roam Canada’s Wendigo Point – and it’s even worse when they come close to a real encounter with it!
Strange happenings keep interrupting Alistair and Diana’s well-deserved honeymoon. And when one of the lodge guests goes missing, the team has another puzzling case to solve before more people vanish mysteriously into the snowy night . . .
The ‘hugely entertaining’ (Booklist) Holy Terrors Mysteries are perfect for fans of Simon R. Green’s urban fantasy novels and authors like Jim Butcher, Terry Pratchett and Ben Aaronovitch, as well as those who enjoy American Horror Story, The X-Files and murder mysteries with a supernatural twist.
Genre: amateur detectives, Private Investigators

My Review:

This is exactly the kind of horror-adjacent story I usually read for Halloween – and I’ve got another one coming later in the week to round things out. What I enjoy about this series – and this kind of story in general – is that the supernatural/horror elements turn out to be perfectly natural at the end. Because it’s perfectly natural, unfortunately, for humans to behave very badly towards other humans. And that sometimes they try to hide their terribleness through making things go bump in the night.

Not that there’s not plenty of that, too – the other kind of bumping in the night – in this fifth book in the Holy Terrors series. The first book in the series, The Holy Terrors, combined a hilarious send-up of so-called “Reality TV”, especially the kind that pretends to be hunting ghosts or exploring supposedly haunted places, with playing off on a very old joke story in British humor about what “the Bishop said to the Actress” that usually implied some hanky-panky going on behind the scenes.

Which there wasn’t in the earlier books in the series, but there was a handsome young Bishop, Alistair Kincaid, and a beautiful Actress whose career needs a bit of a boost, Diana Hunt. After solving a murder mystery covered in supernatural trapping in that first book, the duo, dubbed “The Holy Terrors” by the press, found themselves getting all sorts of interesting invitations to places all over the country absolutely steeped in old legends with haunting backstories.

Their relationship always had a “will they/won’t they” vibe over the course of the series, a vibe that resolved itself at the end of the previous book, For Better or Murder with a marriage proposal.

Which leads to this story, with Alistair and Diana headed for their honeymoon at a remote tourist lodge in Canada to escape from the press that continues to hound them. Or so they hope.

They should have known better – in more ways than one. The innkeepers are old friends of Diana’s, but the press is relentless and by this point in their relationship you would think they would both be wary of any place calling itself the Wendigo Inn – especially after their at The Pale Rider in the previous book.

The Wendigo Inn isn’t just remote, it’s so remote it has no cell service, no landline, and the radio isn’t nearly as powerful as the innkeepers have led their guests to believe. Which is just when a “hundred year” winter storm traps them at the inn for the duration, and the small party stuck there – the two innkeepers, a wealthy middle-aged couple celebrating their 20th anniversary, and the Holy Terrors – start being picked off one by one by a creature that seems to fit every wild tale of the creature whose legends fill the inn’s library.

With the storm keeping them snowbound, after first the innkeeper husband and then the male half of the wealthy couple are drawn out of the house and into the killing cold of the story, it begins to seem as if they’re re-enacting a version Agatha Christie’s And Then There Were None where only the Wendigo will be left to howl alone in the forest.

Unless nothing is as it’s meant to seem, and there’s a much more human – and mundane – solution to everything Alistair and Diana have seen and heard. Even if it’s not the same solution for everything that has happened on what was supposed to be their peaceful – and press-free – honeymoon.

Escape Rating B: This series is a bit of a mixed-bag for me, but this entry was actually a bit better than the previous. I think because – as much as I enjoy the author’s line of snark – the snarky quips and one-liners were getting laid on a bit thick and it got in the way of the story. Also, the “will they/won’t they” between Alistair and Diana was getting to feel a bit stretched.

I liked the role reversal between the couple, that she’s the one trying to seduce him and he’s the one holding out for marriage, but they’re both single and unattached and clearly attracted to each other and there’s only so long that tension can go on without something snapping somewhere. The series had a bit of a difficulty stretching out the real issues between them – which do exist – and exploring what it would mean to have a relationship in spite of those issues – while not having much in the way of actual serious discussion of the issue because the series doesn’t do that kind of seriousness.

This one was better because their relationship has been acknowledged – although precisely how it will work keeping that relationship could be interesting in later books in the series. Having read a lot of the author’s work, it looks like, at least to this reader, that the relationship part of their stories is looking more and more like the Ishmael Jones series – only with the possibility of a long-term happy ending which was not possible in that series because Ishmael is a seemingly immortal – and unaging – alien while his partner, Penny Belcourt, is merely human.

What I liked about this latest entry in the series, and what made it work for me for this Halloween week, is that the over-the-top snarkiness was dialed back to a reasonable – but still fun – level because their relationship issues finally tripped over into “they absolutely will – and fairly often at that” so their snark is still sharp but not as cutting.

The supernatural elements were meant to distract – and they do that successfully but not for too long. Alistair – and the reader – both figure out that whatever is happening most likely has a human origin. Yet is still gets more than a bit confusing all around when it turns out to be two entirely different human origins that are getting in each other’s way. Although, surprisingly in the end, both have the same motives, and once Alistair starts “following the money” the truth – both truths – finally become clear.

The story was satisfyingly creepy throughout even though we’re aware there MUST be a human involved, with the killer storm adding a realistic layer of actual fear on top of the misdirection-created fear. The ending was tied up all the loose ends nicely – or frostily as the case might be. Diana’s old friends weren’t actually villains, the real villain got their just desserts and the marriage between the Bishop and the Actress looks like its off to a fine start, .

And who knows? There might be – or might have been – a wendigo in the woods after all.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge