Grade A #BookReview: For Services Rendered by Will Thomas

Grade A #BookReview: For Services Rendered by Will ThomasFor Services Rendered (Barker & Llewelyn #17) by Will Thomas
Format: eARC
Source: supplied by publisher via Edelweiss
Formats available: hardcover, ebook, audiobook
Genres: historical fiction, historical mystery
Series: Barker & Llewelyn #17
Pages: 312
Published by Minotaur Books on August 18, 2026
Purchasing Info: Author's Website, Publisher's Website, Amazon, Barnes & Noble, Kobo, Bookshop.org, Better World Books
Goodreads

In London, 1896, private enquiry agent Cyrus Barker's world is upturned when his longtime nemesis, Sebastian Nightwine, previously believed dead, turns up with evil on his mind, launching devastating and secretive attacks against not just Barker, but his network of friends and close associates.

In 1896, Dr. Sun Yat-Sen, would be reformer and revolutionary, turns up in London, running away from China's Imperial Qing Secret Service, who has placed a substantial bounty on his head for his political activities. Captured by those agents, he's imprisoned in the Chinese Embassy until he can be smuggled back to China to face execution.

In the meantime, private enquiry agents Cyrus Barker and Thomas Llewelyn receive the unbelievable news that Sebastian Nightwine is both alive and in London. Not just that, it seems he's taking action against Barker and his close associates. At the same time, they've been hired to find this missing Sun Yat-Sen. With elements of the Chinese secret service, elements of the British government, and Nightwine himself all working against them, Barker & Llewelyn are at risk of being cornered by the deadliest set enemies they've yet faced.

My Review:

For once, the mystery doesn’t begin with a dead body. Not that young Dr. Sun Yat-sen isn’t going to wish he was dead, frequently and often, long before his rescue. And his second rescue. But this one begins with a kidnapping. One that actually happened, whether or not it happened precisely like this.

Dr. Sun Yat-sen, then a young, naïve, intellectual, was kidnapped in London by members of the Chinese Secret Service on October 11, 1896, just as he was in this story. Because he wrote a letter to the Emperor of China suggesting modernization reforms to the ruling government. It did NOT go over well. He managed to escape China but not the Chinese Secret Service. The plan was to smuggle him back to China for his execution in front of the Emperor.

But Sun was not friendless in London. His former teacher, Dr. James Cantle, raised a hue and cry that eventually caught the attention of the press – which in turn embarrassed the Chinese Embassy enough that Sun was released.

So, how do Barker & Llewelyn enter this picture? This is the part of the story where it veers into fiction – and into Barker’s own history. Cantle needs to locate precisely where his former pupil is being held. Barker & Llewelyn are private enquiry agents. Hiring them, or someone like them, would be logical.

But Barker has his own reasons for taking this case, because Sun is not the only person in London whose forced return to China is on the Emperor’s ‘wish list’. The Emperor would also like Barker’s head separated from his body – and those of all the friends he brought with him to London when he fled China.

Barker also has an old enemy more than willing to facilitate that return – as long as he gets paid for it. Either the Emperor will pay him for delivery of Sun AND Barker, or Barker will pay Sebastian Nightwine for his villainy. Just not in the same coin.

Escape Rating A: I was trying to hold onto this for a while, because now I’m caught up with the Barker & Llewelyn series until the next book comes out. But I NEEDED a book that would absorb me from the first page, and I knew this absolutely would. Which it definitely did.

One of the things that makes this series so compelling is the way that it is in a kind of dialogue with the Sherlock Holmes stories AND takes many of its cues and its cases from the actual history of the time in which it is set.

I originally started the series, back at the first book, Some Danger Involved, BECAUSE of the resemblance to Holmes. Barker & Holmes would have been contemporaries if they had lived, and would have dealt with the same issues and at least one of the same cases. But Holmes’ view of the Victorian world in which he lived was from the perspective of an insider. While not an aristocrat, Holmes was a member of the ‘squirearchy’, his family were wealthy landowners – just not titled ones.

Barker is an outsider. A Scot instead of an Englishman, raised in China by missionary parents who died early and left him to fend for himself from a VERY young age. He has acquired wealth but did not inherit it and has a broader view of his world – and the variety of people living in it – than Holmes ever did.

One of the advantages of this series being written now and not as it was happening – as Conan Doyle did – is that the author can make comments on events of the time without needing to worry about tweaking the noses of the powers-that-be. Historical events can be used as background and backdrop and can be commented upon from Barker’s outsider perspective. And very frequently are.

That’s what makes this particular story so interesting. On the one hand, the incident with Dr. Sun Yat-sen is part of the historic record. The man was a bit of an idealistic revolutionary, he did write the letter, he was kidnapped, he was ‘detained’ at the Chinese Embassy and he was released as occurred in the story. All of that is real.

At the same time, Barker’s reasons for becoming involved are very much wrapped up in his personal history. He is one of the targets, as are all of his oldest and dearest friends. He wants revenge on his old enemy, Sebastian Nightwine, every bit as much as Nightwine wants the same on Barker. (That Sebastian Nightwine strongly resembles one of Holmes’ nemeses, Sebastian Moran, emphasizes the resemblances between the two detectives that much more clearly if you recognize it, but Nightwine is obviously a thoroughgoing blackguard who clearly deserves what happens to him whether you do or not.)

So the story is running on two parallel tracks. There’s the investigation into Sun’s disappearance, and then there’s the investigation into Nightwine’s motives and whereabouts as he’s planning to scoop up Barker and his old friends to maximize his payout and his revenge. One part, Sun’s disappearance, involves a lot of political shenanigans, creative publicity and more than a bit manipulation all the way around. The other part, Barker and Nightwine’s longstanding enmity winding up to a bloody, mess close is the part that keeps the pace of the story moving swiftly from Nightwine’s opening salvo to the solution of Barker’s final problem with the man.

A problem that this time is absolutely – and truly finally – resolved. Not that Barker won’t have an old – or a new – enemy to thwart in future books in the series.

Just as with yesterday’s book, this is a “cry because it’s over, smile because it happened” dilemma, but at least in the case of Barker & Llewelyn I can rest assured that the 18th book in the series, Farewell Ophelia, is scheduled for publication August of next year. Thank goodness!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge