#BookReview: Six Savage Thrones by Holly Race

#BookReview: Six Savage Thrones by Holly RaceSix Savage Thrones (Queens of Elben, #2) by Holly Race
Format: eARC
Source: supplied by publisher via Edelweiss
Formats available: hardcover, paperback, ebook, audiobook
Genres: epic fantasy, fantasy, fantasy romance, historical fantasy, romantasy
Series: Queens of Elben #2
Pages: 400
Published by Orbit on June 16, 2026
Purchasing Info: Author's WebsitePublisher's WebsiteAmazonBarnes & NobleKoboBookshop.orgBetter World Books
Goodreads

From a major new voice in epic fantasy, Six Savage Thrones continues the Queens of Elben trilogy, a breathtaking epic fantasy of dragons, courtly intrigue, sapphic yearning, and the wives of Henry VIII defying their destiny.

DIVIDED HE WINS, UNITED HE FALLS.

The kingdom of Elben is in turmoil. One of its magical palaces lies in ruins at the bottom of the ocean and the king is on the hunt for the traitor Queen Seymour. He will not stop until he brings her to her knees.

No one would ever suspect Queen Howard of treachery or spy craft, but she is no longer content to be the king's songbird. She will see to Henry's downfall. But there is a new gentleman at court, one who seems to know more about her true motives than he should—is he friend or foe?

Queen Cleves has already survived a war. She knows what she must do to protect herself, but now she finds herself fighting a longing for another queen that is so fierce it might swallow her up.

Amidst the turmoil, King Henry's sister Cecilia vies for the power she has been denied. But the queens will soon learn they must work together to break the bonds that tie them to the king. For Henry is delving deeper into strange old magics, ones that could birth a monster.

My Review:

The first book in the Queens of Elben trilogy, Six Wild Crowns, portrayed an alternate-history fantasy version of England that was deeply invested in the history that we all think we know about the Tudor dynasty, Henry VIII, and his really messy romantic and dynastic obsessions. But this trilogy takes that old memory rhyme about the fates of his six wives, “Divorced, beheaded, died. Divorced, beheaded, survived.” and turns it into an entirely different saga of a king who is magically bound to have six wives AT THE SAME TIME to help him maintain the protective border around his island kingdom.

Naturally, all is not as it initially seems, or this story wouldn’t be half so fascinating. Which it absolutely is. (Of course it is, the original material has been captivating the minds of historians and historical fiction readers for literally centuries!)

By putting a fantasy twist on this well-known historical saga, rather than a retelling, the author is able to not just show these events from the many important and available female perspectives, but to recast the story as something truly magical and, fascinatingly, potentially change the ending. Something that retellings are often loath to do.

So, instead of Henry’s six wives – and various mistresses – overlapping but mostly existing sequentially, all six wives are alive and queenly at the same time. The minute they start working together in Six Wild Crowns, instead of against each other as they’re intended to by the men in power, the story was off and running.

Portrait of Anne of Cleves by Hans Holbein the Younger c. 1539

But they slipped under the ‘radar’ in that first book because Henry and his male advisors all underestimated them. As men do. Once the queens’ plan was revealed, the powers-that-be, again, meaning men, targeted the queens and their allies individually and collectively.

This second book is what happens while they are all in the king’s crosshairs. They know they are targets. He knows they are plotting. The situation is going to get bloodier, and it does.

At the same time, more is revealed about the situation in Elben as a whole. The country is literally rotting from within. The gods are not happy with this situation – at all – but the patriarchy’s god, Cernunnos, is rapacious and determined to hold onto his power through Henry no matter who or what gets sacrificed in their collective rampage. The queens’ patron goddess, Medren, may have right on her side, but she is a nurturing goddess whose first recourse is not violence. Although I wouldn’t be surprised if she reaches that point in the third book. The cliche about “nature, red in tooth and claw”, exists for a reason and this story is likely to get there before it can end.

This reader, at least, certainly hopes so, because this second book concludes in a very dark place under very desperate circumstances. The queens may be in mourning and on the run, but the future is still in their hands. They just need to seize it before it’s too late.

Escape Rating B+: This is the middle book in a projected trilogy. And, like most middle books, the situations are always darkest just before they turn completely black. So this isn’t exactly the fun part of the story. The quintessential ‘middle book’ is Tolkien’s The Two Towers, which ended with Frodo carried off as a potentially dead captive in Mordor as Sam, now the ringbearer, follows mournfully behind. Middle books don’t get any darker than that, although this one comes close.

Portrait of a Young Woman believed to be Catherine Howard from the Workshop of Hans Holbein the Younger c. 1540-1545

Which is where that B+ rating comes in. Because I adored the first book in THIS trilogy, Six Wild Crowns. I HAD to find out what happened next because THAT story ended when the queens had just ripped the bandage off all of the lies the population of Elben have been brainwashed with for centuries. But they’ve also revealed their queenly conspiracy to their kingly enemy, Henry VIII, and lost one of their number in the process.

This is the part of the story where the noose tightens around all their remaining necks, even as they do their damndest to maneuver said noose around Henry’s instead. But Henry possesses ALL the levers of power as well as the magic he’s stolen from them, and he knows how to use both to his advantage much better than they do their own combined powers.

Part of what makes this trilogy work, at least so far, is the way that it gets inside the heads of each of the queens. Not all at once, because that would probably be too much of a split focus, but one or two – or in this case three.

Six Wild Crowns was told from the alternating perspectives of Queen (Anne) Boleyn and Queen (Jane) Seymour. In that opening story, we watched Boleyn maneuver her way into Henry’s bed, discover the truth of his power and her own her part in how that power was used and how he used his queens up in the process, seduced or manipulated (or both) Seymour and eventually the other queens into her nascent conspiracy, and pay the ultimate price for it.

This time we have three perspectives, Queen (Anne of) Cleves, maintaining her own heart and her own council but in the conspiracy up to her neck, Queen (Katharine) Howard, the youngest and most seemingly twitter-pated queen, the one who no one, not even Henry, believes has enough intelligence to understand the stakes, and a new/old player on the board, Dowager Queen Cecilia of Capetia (France). Cecilia is Henry’s younger sister, and stands in for the real historical Mary Tudor – who wasn’t, at least as far as history records her – nearly so bloodthirsty. Or psychopathic.

Portrait of Mary Tudor by Jan Gossaert c. 1516

The inclusion of Cecilia both rewrites the history of the Tudors as we know them and provides a perspective aligned with the powers-that-be that doesn’t underestimate the queens because she is one herself. But also gives the reader a new character through whom we can see just how far Henry has fallen from the heroic older brother that Cecilia once loved.

Underlying the bloody, fascinating drama of the Tudors is a fantasy about old gods being replaced by new beliefs AND about a rebellion to overthrow the entire heteropatriarchy to right the balance. Which means that the romances that occur in this saga, while they may be mostly tragic – at least so far – also take place across the spectrum of human sexuality. That love is all there is is all we know of love – even when their world is crashing down around them.

In conclusion, a few final thoughts. First, IMHO this isn’t technically a romantasy. At this point in the story I’m not sure ANY of the participants have even the hope of a happy ending. This isn’t a happy story but the real life version wasn’t either. But I do think it has some of the same feels, so if you like your romantasy on the tragic side, there’s plenty of that going on so far.

Second, because this is a middle book, the story neither begins nor ends here. Meaning that readers absolutely should not start here. And, frankly, I wouldn’t blame anyone who hasn’t already started the trilogy for waiting until the third book comes out. This one ends in a literal hell of a place. Which is right and fitting and feels like the way the story should be going at this point, but dammit I wish I knew when the conclusion was coming because I’m gasping to see how it all ends.

An end which, as I’m writing this review, is nowhere in sight. YET.

A++ #BookReview: Six Wild Crowns by Holly Race

A++ #BookReview: Six Wild Crowns by Holly RaceSix Wild Crowns (Queens of Elben, #1) by Holly Race
Format: eARC
Source: supplied by publisher via Edelweiss
Formats available: hardcover, ebook, audiobook
Genres: epic fantasy, fantasy, fantasy romance, historical fantasy, romantasy
Series: Queens of Elben #1
Pages: 416
Published by Orbit on June 10, 2025
Purchasing Info: Author's WebsitePublisher's WebsiteAmazonBarnes & NobleKoboBookshop.orgBetter World Books
Goodreads

The king has been appointed by god to marry six queens. Those six queens are all that stand between the kingdom of Elben and ruin. Or so we have been told.
Each queen vies for attention. Clever, ambitious Boleyn is determined to be Henry's favourite. And if she must incite a war to win Henry over? So be it.
Seymour acts as spy and assassin in a court teeming with dragons, backstabbing courtiers and strange magic. But when she and Boleyn become the unlikeliest of things - allies - the balance of power begins to shift. Together they will discover an ancient, rotting magic at Elben's heart. A magic that their king will do anything to protect.
A captivating epic fantasy filled with dragons, court politics and sapphic yearning, perfect for fans of The Priory of the Orange Tree and House of the Dragon.

My Review:

I got hooked on all things Tudor when I was 12 years old and saw the movie Anne of the Thousand Days sprawled across the wide screen of a local movie theater. The opening scene of the movie, at least the way I remember it, was the scene of Henry chasing Anne on horseback as she gleefully gallops ahead of him.

Portrait of Anne Boleyn, Henry’s second queen; a copy of a lost original painted around 1534

I saw that scene again in my mind’s eye at the opening of Six Wild Crowns, because Boleyn herself is thinking of her first meeting with the King, and how that meeting led her to her wedding to that very same man as this historical fantasy revision of the story begins.

From there, the story is off to the races, but to a race that is able to take just the kind of fantastic twists and turns that fantasy allows while still being grounded, steeped, and perfumed by the historical facts, lies and manipulations that were part of the history that has been recorded – by Henry and his court, because they were the victors in the history that we were all taught.

Which is where the path between real history and fantasy history both meet and diverge. They meet in the sense that the history of fantasy England, Elben in this tour-de-force of epic historical fantasy and romantasy, is the story of what has been taught to the people of Elben. What they, from the lowest commoner to the six queens of the realm, has been taught to believe about the blessings their god, Cernunnos, has granted to their land, their king, and their people.

That Elben is protected by a magical boundary, that that boundary is embodied in the strength of the king, and that the king’s protection and his burden are supported by his six queens in their six castles at the borders of their land. And that their god, Cernunnos, created it all to protect the land where he is worshipped.

This “origin story”, believed by all, puts a fantasy spin on the reign of Henry VIII, his obsessive pursuit of a male heir, and especially his marital excesses and executions. To protect Elben, the king is required to have six wives at all times to occupy those six castles that protect his realm.

Of course, those queens are expected to be each other’s quiet, polite, civilized enemies. Because that’s what their world believes of women. Because that’s the way the court expresses its preferences. And, as it turns out, because that’s what’s necessary to keep the queens from banding together and learning the truth about the real source of the blessing of Elben, the reason why it’s fading, and the best way to resolve what’s needed to bring it back to full power and protection.

And it’s Boleyn’s rebellion that sets the whole treasonous plot in motion. A rebellion that began, as all the most interesting rebellions do, with a secret, a lie, and a romance for the ages. Just not the one that our history, or theirs, would ever have led us to expect.

Portrait of Henry VIII by Joos van Cleve, c. 1531

Escape Rating A++: As you might guess from the rating, I’m here to SQUEE. My fascination with the Tudors started early and extends to the present day, so I was all in on the concept the minute I saw the blurb for this book. But I’ll confess that I was deeply afraid that the actual story would be like the bear dancing, you’re not surprised it’s done well, you’re astonished that it’s done at all. In other words, I loved the concept but couldn’t figure out if or how it would actually work.

I was blown away by just how very well it works – and how very firmly it stands on all three of its ‘legs’. That the fantasy worldbuilding is deep and well-executed, that the romances are all romantic, often tragic, and very much not the same as each other, and the way that the known and popularized history holds the whole thing up, brings a lot of bright and sparkling – and dark and gloomy – aspects to the court and to these well-known characters and makes them feel REAL because in their heart of hearts – and ours – they are.

They just get to shine and especially to change some of their fates and the fate of their world because this is fantasy and not historical fiction after all – and it’s all the better a story for it.

What makes the story work is the way that the author has used what we already know about the characters to move the story into the realms of what might have been, and that includes not just the royals but also the advisors, councilors and hangers on. It’s not just that Aragon and Boleyn and Seymour are plotting against each other – because they were – but also that More and Wolsey and Cromwell are plotting against each other, against the queens, and plotting with the queens against each other, because they were, too.

(And if you like that part of the story, take a look at the King’s Fool mysteries (starting with Courting Dragons) by Jeri Westerson. Because that intimate view of the court, its machinations, and Henry’s inadequacies and insecurities, is a similar view to the one in THIS story.)

Portrait of Jane Seymour by Hans Holbein the Younger ca. 1536-37
Portrait of Jane Seymour by Hans Holbein the Younger ca. 1536-37

Told from the perspective of Seymour and Boleyn, the way that their relationship is allowed to happen, and the way it morphs because their relationship with Henry happen at the same time, gives a whole new spin on events as they occur – especially as we get a LOT of Seymour’s point of view and it’s even more fascinating because history records so little of her and this story has so much and it feels like it fits perfectly. It also means that we’re not surprised that part of the spin is the realization that all the queens have been fed a load of codswallop to keep them complacent in their subservient roles – and that this is not the way things were meant to be.

And that the patriarchy is doing its damndest to keep them from discovering a truth that will set them free if they can manage to wrest control. OTOH it’s a lot like the feminist interpretations/retellings of stories like Madeline Miller’s Circe and Ava Reid’s Lady Macbeth, BUT, and this is a huge but that makes things so much better, those stories were told as historical myths, so the male-dominant endings couldn’t be changed. Six Wild Crowns is straight-up fantasy, so there’s definitely a possibility that the patriarchy could get at least a bit of its comeuppance. Which we won’t know for a while because this is a projected trilogy and we’re only in book 1 so far.

I know I’m all over the map on this thing, because I loved it really, really hard and I kind of want to tell you everything so you’ll love it too while at the same time I don’t want to spoil it for you because I want you to read it.

If you’ve been dying to see Six, if you adore the deeply researched historical fiction of Alison Weir, if you fell for the Tudors in any of the many, many movie and TV versions, if you’re looking for something that combines the best of romantasy with the corrupt political machinations of contemporary epic fantasy, Six Wild Crowns will be your jam every bit as much as it is mine. I’m already on those proverbial tenterhooks waiting for book 2 in the trilogy, and wondering which queens will be at the forefront of upsetting Henry’s applecart even further as the story continues.