The Eight Heartbreaks of Hanukkah by Jean Meltzer Format: eARC
Source: supplied by publisher via Edelweiss
Formats available: hardcover, paperback, ebook, audiobook
Genres: contemporary romance, Hanukkah romance, holiday romance, second chance romance
Pages: 368
Published by Mira on October 21, 2025
Purchasing Info: Author's Website, Publisher's Website, Amazon, Barnes & Noble, Kobo, Bookshop.org, Better World Books
Goodreads
Can these exes rekindle their love this Hanukkah?
Evelyn Schwartz has the perfect Hanukkah planned: eight jam-packed days producing the live-action televised musical of A Christmas Carol. Who needs family when you’ve got long hours, impossible deadlines, and your dream job? That is, until an accident on set lands her in the medical bay with one of her chronic migraines, and she’s shocked to find her ex-husband, David Adler, filling in for the usual studio doctor.
It’s been two years since David walked away from Evelyn and their life in Manhattan, and his ex-wife is still the same workaholic who puts her career before everything else—especially her health. But when Evelyn begins hallucinating “ghosts” tied to her past heartbreaks, and every single one leads to David, he finds himself spending much more time with her than he anticipated. And denying the still-smoldering chemistry between them becomes impossible.
As Evelyn revisits her ghosts of Hanukkah past, she and David both begin to wonder if they can have a Hanukkah future. But with a high-stakes production ramping up the pressure on Evelyn, and troublesome spirits forcing them both to confront their most difficult shared memories, it might just take a Hanukkah miracle for these two exes to light the flame on their second-chance at love.
My Review:
Everyone knows the story of Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol – if not from the book itself then from one – or more likely more – of the many, many TV and movie adaptations. My two favorites are still Mr. Magoo’s cartoon from the 1960s and the Muppets’ version from the 1990s.
The idea of the story is eternal, that anyone can atone, that anyone can be redeemed, that anyone can learn to celebrate the true meaning of Christmas with a big enough ‘wake-up’ call. Even if it’s not really a real wake-up call as it is in the recent A Christmas Witness. Which maybe worked even better because it wasn’t exactly real.
After all, even in Dickens’ original version, it did all turn out to be a dream. Just a very powerful one.
This is the first Hanukkah version of Dickens’ classic that I’ve ever read. (If this idea has been done before, please, please, PLEASE let me know in the comments! The original Dickens’ story is one of my favorites, but Hanukkah is my holiday so more versions of this combo are VERY tempting!)
The Eight Heartbreaks of Hanukkah takes that old, familiar, much beloved Christmas classic and gives it both a Jewish twist and a whole lot more time to work its holiday magic. The spirits needed to work their magic on Scrooge in a single night, where the Heartbreaks of Hanukkah have eight whole nights to weave their spell.
And they’ll need every night of it, because Evelyn Schwartz is a really tough nut to crack and she has a lot of heartbreak to work her way through this Hanukkah. Which is, at its heart or hers (pun fully intended) a huge part of why Evelyn’s heartbreaks loom so large over the holidays. Because she’s managed her whole life NOT working her way through her trauma and grief.
She shoves it all down, each and every time, and buries herself in work instead of letting herself be buried in her grief. But this Hanukkah it’s time for her to pay the price of all that avoidance.
If she won’t let herself feel her feelings and grieve for her own losses, this Hanukkah, for eight long nights and eight painfully debilitating migraines, they’re coming for her. One night, one loss, one grief, one heartbreak at a time.
Escape Rating B: This is going to be one of those mixed feelings reviews – and I have LOTS of them when it comes to this book.
First, the concept behind this story is fantastic. A Christmas Carol, with its magical story of redemption, is a beloved classic for a reason. And the idea of putting a Jewish twist on it is so much genius I’m astonished that I haven’t found one before.
Howsomever, the same thing that makes the insta-love in holiday romances work so much better in a Hanukkah romance than a Christmas romance because it has more time to work with had the opposite effect here. Each of Evelyn’s individual heartbreaks was a LOT. Eight of them felt like too many. Not because they weren’t each heartbreaking, but because they were all, sorta/kinda, the SAME heartbreak.
Evelyn’s heartbreaks were ALL Bruno. Not a person, but the song from Encanto. As in “We Don’t Talk About Bruno.” Evelyn Schwartz doesn’t talk about her problems, or her hurts or her worries or her griefs. She pushes them down and away so that she can bury herself in her work and push them away even more.
That Evelyn is a television producer makes her self-appointed task VERY easy. There’s always another crisis, there’s always another last minute change, and there’s always another male studio executive looking for her to fail and prove him right that TV producing is a man’s job and women just can’t cut it.
So Evelyn’s eight heartbreaks, while they have different causes, all boil down to the same thing in the end. That Evelyn buries her feelings in work every single time. To the point that when she and her then-husband had to bury their baby girl, they couldn’t grieve together because Evelyn couldn’t let herself feel her own feelings and left him alone with his.
Evelyn’s eight heartbreaks visit her, night after night, because her long-buried feelings and her lifelong ambitions have had a head on collision. Literally as the situation has sent her migraines into overdrive.
She’s the Executive Producer of a planned production of A Christmas Carol scheduled to be performed and broadcast LIVE on Christmas Eve. If the program is successful in EVERY SINGLE WAY, it’s the making of her career and the fulfillment of all her professional dreams. But if it isn’t absolutely perfect, it will mark the end of those same dreams.
Just as Evelyn is gearing up and grinding towards the final rehearsals, as her expensive, mercurial, high-maintenance star is about to arrive on set – a different issue arises in the person of her ex-husband David, as the studio’s stand-in medical doctor while the regular MD is on vacation.
Their chemistry is still incendiary – like kerosene and matches. But there’s still plenty smoldering under that white-hot surface. They’ve never gotten over each other, but they’ve also never gotten past the grief over their shared loss. And they need to – whether to make a new something together or make new lives separately – because neither of them has moved on an inch in any of the ways that matter.
In the end, just as the story is Evelyn’s redemption, or at least her path towards letting people in, letting herself feel her own feelings, a somewhat healthier work-life balance AND her acceptance that therapy might help her with all of the above, the story does redeem itself. I absolutely loved its multiple twists on the message of A Christmas Carol and the way it made me rethink the whole story at the end. But it is STILL a lot. A lot of heartbreak, a lot of grief and a lot of arguments leading to a hard-fought-for happy ending.
But this is absolutely not your typical holiday romance. It’s certainly not a romcom. If that’s what you’re looking for, or if it’s not what you’re looking for right now, it may not be the right book or the right time. Because it takes a lot of heartbreak to bring about this particular holiday miracle. A situation which will put some readers in the holiday spirit while perhaps making others reach for the holiday spirits. Your reading – and possibly drinking – mileage may vary.
All Wrapped Up in You (Home Sweet Holidays) by
The thing about these holiday shorts series(es), both this year’s
Howsomever, this story in this year’s
Even then, they only sorta/kinda meet. They recognize each other from the comedy club – but still don’t know they are neighbors.
I listened to this one, and Andi Eloise (Piper) and Robert Hatchet (Scott), did a terrific job voicing their characters. The audio versions of these original stories are the perfect length for my daily drive and these stories are a perfect way to spend that drive and get a happy, sweet, pick-me-up story into the bargain.
Christmas at the Shelter Inn (Shelter Springs #1) by
Last holiday season, I kicked off my participation in the #2024HoHoHoRat with
I’ll admit that I do have a quibble, and it’s what’s keeping this story from matching the A- grade I gave
Merry and Bright (Home Sweet Holidays) by
Escape Rating A-: Just as in
Burn the World Down (Unsanctioned) by
But fate intervened when Nash and Elliott enlisted in the Army, Elliott was killed in action and Nash and his grief were recruited into the kind of operations that get blacked out in someone’s service record. The kind of operations that Vander Norcross used to run. (I expect
One caveat that isn’t exactly fair, is that I haven’t liked most of the author’s recent series covers, and I’m not all that fond of this one, either (picture at right for comparison). OTOH, the Special Edition paperback covers have been gorgeous. I want to say that your reading mileage may vary, but the book is the same regardless of the artwork on the cover. This time around at least we get to see the cover model’s whole, entire head and face, which wasn’t true for 
Snow Place Like Home (Home Sweet Holidays) by
Second Chance Romance (Harlot's Bay, #2) by
The first book in this series,
In the end, I enjoyed the romance and LOVED the characters (in multiple senses of that word) in Harlot’s Bay. (I have a big soft spot in my heart for the Nasty Wenches Book Club.) I really hope we get to go back.
Saving Mr. Norcross (Norcross Security) by
Considering that Vander Norcross first met his future wife, then-SFPD Detective Brynn Sullivan, when she was undercover in a motorcycle gang (their story is
The rescue/breakout scenes were a whole lot of adrenaline-fuelled fun, as Vander is breaking out because he knows Brynn is coming to get him and he’s figured out what’s going on and thinks he can negotiate his way out. Not that he’s not willing to make a mess and take down a lot of bad guys, but he’s figured out what’s behind the whole thing. While someone is definitely going to go down for this, it’s not going to be him and Rhys if they can just get out of the way.
The Most Unusual Haunting of Edgar Lovejoy by
Escape Rating A+: I’m going to TRY to tone down the ‘SQUEE’ in this review, but it’s NOT going to be easy. This turned out to be a single-sitting read for me – and an utterly rapt one at that – because I loved this story EVEN MORE than I expected to. And I came into it expecting a LOT, because of just how much I enjoyed the author’s previous ‘holiday’ romance,
In the end, it’s a lot more about Edgar’s learning to step outside of his fear bubble and starting to deal with the traumas that created that bubble than it is about the ghosts that both cause and represent that fear. In other words, the paranormal elements aren’t the focus of the story. Edgar’s healing and his relationship with Jamie, along with Jamie’s standing up for themselves in the face of their family’s coercions – and making it stick this time no matter the cost – are the focus(es). Foci. Whichever word is correct the story’s focus is on the living and not the haunting dead.
Love at First Fright by
Escape Rating B-: First of all, it was driving me crazy that I was sure that I recently read a book where the writer protagonist had the same variety of writer’s block that Rosemary has in this story – and I had and it’s Stacy Sivinski’s