#BookReview: We’ll Prescribe You Another Cat by Syou Ishida translated by E. Madison Shimoda

#BookReview: We’ll Prescribe You Another Cat by Syou Ishida translated by E. Madison ShimodaWe'll Prescribe You Another Cat (We'll Prescribe You a Cat, #2) by Syou Ishida, E. Madison Shimoda
Format: eARC
Formats available: hardcover, ebook, audiobook
Genres: literary fiction, magical realism, sad fluff, translated fiction, world literature
Series: We'll Prescribe You a Cat #2
Pages: 304
Published by Berkley on September 2, 2025
Purchasing Info: Author's WebsitePublisher's WebsiteAmazonBarnes & NobleKoboBookshop.orgBetter World Books
Goodreads

The Kokoro Clinic for the Soul reopens in this delightful follow-up to the award-winning, bestselling Japanese novel We’ll Prescribe You a Cat.
It’s time to revisit the Kokoro Clinic for the Soul.
Though it’s a mysteriously located clinic with an uncertain address, it can always be found by those who need it. And the clinic has proven time after time that a prescribed cat has the power to heal the emotional wounds of its patients. This charming sequel introduces a new lovable cast of healing cats, from Kotetsu, a four-month-old Bengal who unleashes his boundless energy by demolishing bed linens and curtains, to tenacious and curious Shasha, who doesn’t let her small size stop her from anything, and the most lovable yet lazy cat Ms. Michiko, who is as soft and comforting as mochi.
As characters from one chapter appear as side characters in the next, we follow a young woman who cannot help pushing away the man who loves her, a recently widowed grandfather whose grandson refuses to leave his room, the family of a young woman who struggle to understand each other, and an anxious man who works at a cat shelter seeking to show how the most difficult cats can be the most rewarding. This moving, magical novel of interconnected tales proves the strength in the unfathomable bond between cats and people.

My Review:

I picked this up for three reasons. First and foremost, the first book in the series, the titular We’ll Prescribe You a Cat, was adorable. Second, the cover picture for this second book is just really, really cute, and two cats really are better than one. Third, I was looking for a bit of a comfort read as our trip ended – and I just missed our own cats something terrible in spite of spending the first part of the trip sharing a very insistent feline and visiting a cat cafe at the end because we weren’t getting back to our own cats quickly enough.

As is often the case with this particular type of comfort read, sad fluff book, it’s a collection of mini-stories wrapped around a place, in this case the slightly magical but borderline real Kokoro Clinic for the Soul. The stories aren’t just loosely connected by the place, but also the characters in the stories are loosely connected to each other.

One young woman uses her prescribed cat to put off the “we need to talk” conversation with the boyfriend that she’s sure is about to break up with her. Her best friend is prescribed a cat to help her deal with her resentment of her mother’s extreme favoritism towards her brother. And her brother, well, her brother Tomoya’s work at a cat rescue organization turns out to lie at the heart of the Kokoro Clinic – even if Tomoya himself isn’t aware of it – at all.

Although his cat certainly is.

Escape Rating C: Pardon me for mixing animal metaphors, but after finishing this second book in the series I’m inclined to say that We’ll Prescribe You a Cat might have been better as a ‘one-trick pony’.

Alternatively, it could be that as a cat lover myself, I’m not sure I’m willing to watch Nikké the cat – or his person Tomoya – suffer through Nikké’s very long decline just so that we can watch more people get matched up with more cats.

Either way, the idea behind this series seems like a story that was good once but loses something with repeated applications – even if some of the characters within its pages definitely NEED to be prescribed more than one cat.

As much as I enjoyed the first book, I think that this second one fell flat for me because we already know the twist at the end. The big reveal at the end of We’ll Prescribe You a Cat, as much as it was foreshadowed in the story, was still a sad but delightful surprise. That the magical realism of the setup allowed for Nikké and Chitose to pay their survival forward to others of their kind was both charming and touching. And it still kind of is, but it’s also played for laughs this time around more than was comfortable for this reader, particularly considering the price that Nikké and his person are both paying for it.

And at the same time, the idea that a cat is being mischievous even as he’s winding up his ninth life along with a whole lot of people – and cats – is very, well, cat. But this one broke my heart more than a bit, and not in a good way.

There are at least two more books in the series that have yet to be translated into English. I’m not sure whether I’ll pick them up or not. I love the idea of being prescribed a cat, but the way the overall story seems to be working out gives me the weepies in the worst way.

Your reading mileage on this one may vary, and probably varies significantly depending on how recently you might have lost a beloved companion animal. (I still miss Lucifer a LOT)

#BookReview: We’ll Prescribe You a Cat by Syou Ishida, translated by E. Madison Shimoda

#BookReview: We’ll Prescribe You a Cat by Syou Ishida, translated by E. Madison ShimodaWe'll Prescribe You a Cat by Syou Ishida, E. Madison Shimoda
Format: eARC
Formats available: hardcover, ebook, audiobook
Genres: literary fiction, magical realism, translated fiction, world literature
Series: We'll Prescribe You a Cat #1
Pages: 304
Published by Berkley on March 8, 2023
Purchasing Info: Author's WebsitePublisher's WebsiteAmazonBarnes & NobleKoboBookshop.orgBetter World Books
Goodreads

A cat a day keeps the doctor away…Discover the award-winning, bestselling Japanese novel that has become an international sensation in this utterly charming, vibrant celebration of the healing power of cats.Tucked away in an old building at the end of a narrow alley in Kyoto, the Kokoro Clinic for the Soul can only be found by people who are struggling in their lives and genuinely need help. The mysterious clinic offers a unique treatment to those who find their way it prescribes cats as medication. Patients are often puzzled by this unconventional prescription, but when they “take” their cat for the recommended duration, they witness profound transformations in their lives, guided by the playful, empathetic, occasionally challenging yet endearing cats.Throughout the pages, the power of the human-animal bond is revealed as a disheartened businessman finds unexpected joy in physical labor, a young girl navigates the complexities of elementary school cliques, a middle-aged man struggles to stay relevant at work and home, a hardened bag designer seeks emotional balance, and a geisha finds herself unable to move on from the memory of her lost cat. As the clinic’s patients navigate their inner turmoil and seek resolution, their feline companions lead them toward healing, self-discovery, and newfound hope.

My Review:

Kyoto’s Kokoro Clinic for the Soul can only be found if you really, really need it. You’ll probably only even hear the rumor about its existence – and a rather confused and confusing rumor at that – if you are in need of the service they provide.

If there’s an ache in your soul – even if you think that ache is in your mind, and you have the patience to circle the block and not let yourself get convinced that you’re, pardon the expression, barking up the wrong tree, you’ll see a poorly maintained building in the shadows behind newer and much taller ones, down an alleyway that can be found “east of Takoyakushi Street, south of Tominokoji Street, west of Rokkaku Street, north of Fuyacho Street, Nakagyō Ward, Kyoto.”

It’s the place where the young and slightly scatterbrained Dr. Nikké and his taciturn receptionist Chitose will prescribe you a cat for whatever ails you.

Shuta Kagawa is depressed and miserable. His job at a seemingly successful financial management firm is actually hell on Earth, with an absolute demon of a boss. (Not literally. Probably not literally. Comparisons could certainly be drawn). He wants to quit, but he doesn’t want to disappoint his parents. He wants a real life instead of a sentence to purgatory. He thinks that the Kokoro Clinic provides some kind of mental health therapy.

Which they do, just not in any way that he imagines. They prescribe him a cat named Bee. And she gives him something to focus on besides his own angst. She changes his life – sometimes willingly on his part, but mostly not so much – and the lives of everyone around him. That the people around him at the end are absolutely NOT the same people around him at the beginning is just part of his cure.

Shuta and Bee’s story is the first thread of a delightful tapestry, that gets woven, one prescription – and one cat – at a time, by two practitioners who know just what it means to leave a part of your soul behind.

Escape Rating B: There are a LOT of books similar to this one, where the central location is mysterious or mythical or just difficult to find, where that place connects a series of stories that at first don’t seem connected at all, where there’s just a touch of magic or magical realism, where the overall experience ends up being a bit bittersweet. Not all of the vignettes have happy endings, but they all have cathartic ones.

I picked this up because I LOVE those kinds of books, and this one has cats, which is always a win for me. Certainly the idea of being “prescribed” a cat caught my imagination, as it did several people who saw this title in my Stacking the Shelves and Sunday Posts where this title was featured. Because really, a prescription for a cat – complete with cat! What’s not to love?

But, if the concept behind the prescription seems a bit familiar, that’s only because it has become so through books such as Before the Coffee Gets Cold and many others. Of the ones I’ve read so far, this reminds me of the most is The Full Moon Coffee Shop, so if you liked that you’ll probably like this and vice versa.

What makes this one work is the way that the prescriptions all have different results. Shuta Kagawa does, in the end, adopt Bee. They rescue each other, which is what often happens with companion animals who become part of our lives and hearts. It’s kind of what we expect in ALL the stories  – but that’s not what actually happens.

In other cases, the cat opens people’s eyes to their own situations. The cat doesn’t need rescuing, it’s the human who needs a different perspective – even if that perspective is that it’s time to let go – whether of a human relationship that isn’t working or holding on too tightly to the grief over the loss of a pet. Different situations require different forms of closure, after all.

The magical realism magic of this story rests in the disappearing/reappearing clinic and its origin story, which the reader is led to slowly and carefully over the course of the book. But the fun magic is that Dr. Nikké’s and receptionist Chitose’s labor of love for both cats and humans becomes so successful over this course of prescriptions that it looks like they’ll be keeping their doors open – when they can be found at all – for a long time to come.