Grade A #AudioBookReview: A Labyrinth of Honeybees by Heather Fawcett

Grade A #AudioBookReview: A Labyrinth of Honeybees by Heather FawcettA Labyrinth of Honeybees (Magic & Mystery, #4) by Heather Fawcett
Narrator: Esther Wane
Format: audiobook, ebook
Source: borrowed from Amazon Kindle Unlimited
Formats available: ebook, audiobook
Genres: fantasy, fantasy mystery
Series: Magic & Mystery #4
Pages: 44
Length: 1 hour and 15 minutes
Published by Amazon Original Stories on July 28, 2026
Purchasing Info: Author's WebsitePublisher's WebsiteAmazon
Goodreads

New rulers meddle with the whims of the old gods in a lush and twisty short story of devotion, intrigue, and murder by the New York Times bestselling author of the Emily Wilde series.
At a remote mountain temple, an inquisitor arrives to question a priestess about a pair of murders. The keeper of the sacred garden, its bees, and its ever-changing hedge maze does have her secrets. But what will protecting them cost her as she uncovers layers of conspiracy on both sides?
Heather Fawcett’s A Labyrinth of Honeybees is part of the Magic & Mystery collection, puzzle-box mysteries from top fantasy authors. They can be read or listened to in one enchanting sitting.

My Review:

A Labyrinth of Honeybees reads, and listens, like one of the stories that Cleric Chih records in the Singing Hills Cycle. By that, I mean it reads like a bit of myth, a story that feels like we should be familiar with, but we aren’t because it’s a fictional myth in a fictional world and not our own. But it still reads like it should be a story out of legend.

So this isn’t our world and these definitely aren’t our gods or even gods in our ancient mythologies, but the story plucks at the same set of heartstrings. None of which is a surprise as this entry in the Magic & Mystery collection was written by the author of the Emily Wilde series, and those kinds of universal myths and legends are just the sort of thing that Emily Wilde is looking for.

At the same time, it’s a story about human behavior and godly caprice, and those parts ring true in all of their messy, chaotic glory.

From one perspective, it’s a story about conquest and erasure, wrapped inside a murder investigation.

The priestess of sacred grove is, quite rightly, concerned about the royal inquisitor’s arrival at her tiny, secluded sanctuary. And not just because he’s surrounded by the ghosts of the people he’s “inquisited” to death, and they rather constitute a throng that he can’t see, but she absolutely can.

Ostensibly, he’s there to investigate the deaths of two of his King’s tax collectors. His real mission is to search for the King’s heir, who is missing. Underneath all of that, the King is looking for an excuse to burn the sanctuary, as the conquerors’ religion is not merely monotheistic but is intolerant of all others. But the conquest is recent, the old gods are popular – and populous, there are 83 (or possibly 84) of them! – and the old religion is still deeply rooted among the people where the new regime is hated and feared.

A justification for burning the sacred grove is required, and the King expects his inquisitor to find it. Not create it, because the King’s faith requires justification for all of his murderous deeds. And his inquisitor is a devoted adherent of that faith. But as the saying goes, “man plans, God laughs” which is especially true when there are 83 – or 84 – gods and two of them have conspired in a very specific plan – for the inquisitor.

Escape Rating A: I both read and listened to this one. I listened to it first, and enjoyed the narration by Esther Wane. She did a terrific job of voicing the characters and was an excellent fit for the voice of the priestess who is telling us this story from inside her own head. Which is also a terrific place to be, as she’s mature, a bit world-weary, has run out of fucks to give over the pecadillos of human – and even godly – behavior, but still cares deeply for her people and her goddess even though she’s more than a bit fed up with the trappings of religion.

AND she’s good at keeping her secrets and most of her thoughts behind her teeth, and not showing the fear she absolutely does feel but knows better than to express.

But, as I said earlier, the way this story works feels like the tales that Cleric Chih records, and sometimes tells in Nghi Vo’s Singing Hills Cycle. But that’s a feeling, so if you like the way those stories work you’ll probably enjoy A Labyrinth of Honeybees. But if you’re looking for something that reads like this story, then definitely check out Lois McMaster Bujold’s Penric and Desdemona series, because the way that Penric’s god interferes in his life and inserts chaos into it at every turn are very similar to the mess that the the priestess’ goddess drops into her lap in this story.

I listened to this one, then read the text, because as much as I enjoyed the listening experience – and I did – I started after midnight. The ways this story works are a bit subtle, and a lot of things are implied or hinted at that the reader doesn’t catch until the end. I wanted to make sure I got it all, and had a chance to think about what I got, as this is one of those stories that reads a bit differently once you have all the pieces.

Also, on the first go around I concentrated on the “top” story, about the inquisitor investigating the murders and the interactions between the inquisitor and the priestess. On the second time through the undertones and half-said bits about the new king and the new religion and the problems of conquest and the tensions of repression and cultural erasure peek through the screen of the mystery investigation. Which is exactly right, as both the inquisitor AND the priestess KNOW the investigation is a smokescreen for the real threat from the king, as well as his somewhat exaggerated and at least partly imaginary fears about the power of the old gods.

It was every bit as good a reading experience as it was a listening experience, but I did pick up more nuance on that second time around. So I’m glad I did it, because there’s a LOT packed into this seemingly small story.

A+ #AudioBookReview: A Thousand Painted Hours by Barbara O’Neal

A+ #AudioBookReview: A Thousand Painted Hours by Barbara O’NealA Thousand Painted Hours: A Novel by Barbara O'Neal
Narrator: Sneha Mathan
Format: audiobook, eARC
Source: supplied by publisher via NetGalley
Formats available: hardcover, paperback, ebook, audiobook
Genres: historical fiction, historical romance
Pages: 480
Length: 15 hours and 22 minutes
Published by Brilliance Audio, Lake Union Publishing on August 11, 2026
Purchasing Info: Author's WebsitePublisher's WebsiteAmazonBarnes & NobleBookshop.orgBetter World Books
Goodreads

An epic, emotionally charged novel about love, art, and survival spanning 1900s colonial India to Blitz-era London by the USA Today bestselling author of When We Believed in Mermaids.

In the shadow of the London Blitz, artist Elsie Turner clings fiercely to her canvases, refusing to let war dim the colors that define her. The bombs test her nerve, but the struggle also stirs memories of her golden youth in India and of the long-lost love of her life.

The daughter of a British civil servant in the Himalayan station of Nainital, Elsie crosses cultural divides to forge an unlikely bond with Tanveer Singh, a Sikh prince with hopes, dreams, and far-reaching ideas. What begins as shared sketchbooks and stargazing becomes first love and a secret correspondence. When Elsie’s father is summoned to England, Elsie is severed from the world she knows—and is determined to preserve it through both her art and a connection with Tanveer that endures through the most tumultuous years of their lives.

Across four decades and two continents, Elsie navigates a journey from lush colonial India to war-torn London, amid landscapes of beauty, protest, and peril. As past and present collide, the most impossible choices and sacrifices are yet to be made in the name of love, war, and survival.

My Review:

It starts with a cyanide capsule. Which is a surprising place for a story to start because it has so much potential to be the end. And very nearly is. That opening scene grabs the reader by the throat and doesn’t let go until the end of this utterly absorbing historical romance.

It’s the story in between that captivates. Not just what happens AFTER Elsie Turner is given that capsule, but all the years and events and miles that led up to it – and to the terrible events that nearly bring her story to a premature end.

In the beginning, Elsie, her estranged husband and her beloved mother are caught in the midst of the Blitz. They’re living in London as Neville Chamberlain’s infamous “peace in our time” dies in a hail of bombs. Night after night after night. As the losses and the destruction pile up all around her, renowned artist Elsie Turner is forced to send her most important, and most potentially lucrative post-war, canvases out of London for safekeeping.

Making the decisions about which to secrete away and which to keep with her is just part of Elsie’s trip down memory lane, a trip that has miles to walk before its end. Her paintings, and her memories, take her back in time to her childhood in India, to her first summer with Tanveer Singh and his sister Gurdaya, when Tanveer and Elsie were both eleven, and their lifelong relationship began.

Elsie and Tanveer were each other’s person from the minute they met, and remained so no matter what life and their parents threw at them and pulled them apart. Equal in mind and heart, the world they grew up in seemed determined to keep them separated – and dragged them away from each other, over and over.

Tanveer was the second son of the local maharaja in Nainital. Elsie was the daughter of an English bureaucrat, but her father was the second son of an Earl. Neither Tanveer nor her father expected to inherit their titles, so in childhood Tanveer and Elsie were relatively equal in rank, if not in the eyes of the British Raj. Their mothers were the best of friends, and they were often thrown together and glad of it.

But they belonged together, and they both knew it – even if they also recognized that the world they lived in would not have it. It didn’t stop them from falling in love. It only stopped them from making a life together.

And yet they were never apart, not even when continents separated them. Because they began as true friends, and were intellectual equals, they maintained their friendship with long letters and intellectual discussions. But they never lost their hold on each other, no matter how far apart they might be.

Which was both the tragedy of their lives and the saving of them, sometimes seemingly both at the same time. Until they finally reached a point in their lives when they could tackle the forces against them, together at last.

Escape Rating A+: This was, in a word, “WOW!” I had forgotten just how much I loved epic historical romance – or historical epic romance – and A Thousand Painted Hours is definitely both. And a marvelously compelling example of both as well.

Then I thought about it for a while and realized that it was because such books stopped existing, and I think I know why. Back in the day, when there were a LOT of such books – but they were often stories where the female main character was repeatedly victimized, generally had little agency, and spent a great deal of the book waiting for rescue by the male main character, who may have been one of the people who victimized her early on. (I’m thinking of Kathleen E. Woodiwiss’ books in particular, but this was definitely the trend.)

Tastes changed, and the good parts got thrown out with the bad. The female main character with little to no agency waiting for rescue – the Cinderella trope – became less popular because women’s opportunities changed in the 1970s, and for the better. But we lost the big historical scope of the story along with the passive female main character.

Except for Outlander, of course. Like Claire Randall in Outlander, Elsie Turner may have to deal with the restrictions of her time on the lives of women, but she takes as much control of her life as she can, rails at the unfairness that she can’t control ALL of her circumstances, and then reaches out and takes every scrap of control that she can manage. She becomes an artist against her parents and her eventual husband’s wishes, builds a career and a name for herself, and continues her relationship with Tanveer against not just the odds but in the face of many who are certain he will be her ruin. Or that she will be his.

A Thousand Painted Hours was so marvelous because it combined that huge sweep of history, in this case from the pre-World War I era to the early months of World War II, alongside the falling of the British Raj and the independence movement in India, with a compelling, absorbing romance that is fully engaged with the times in which it is set – because its characters very much are – and we see this tumultuous time through their eyes and experience it through their hearts.

I’m waxing a bit lyrical in this review, but that’s because this story just captivated me so much. I started out listening to it, and the narration by Sneha Mathan was simply lovely. She gave a marvelous performance, absolutely embodied Elsie, but did an excellent job voicing Tanveer as well. I wish I could have listened to the story all the way through, but I was gasping to see if the story could eke out a happy ending. I certainly didn’t expect one. Because I read a LOT faster than an audiobook plays, I switched to text. But it is absolutely worth the time to listen to the whole thing if you have the time and can keep yourself from thumbing ahead. I couldn’t.

While the romance is what holds the story together, what made it work was the way that their relationship is intertwined with so much roiling history. Because tumultuous times, and people’s reactions to them and compromises with them, make the BEST stories, and A Thousand Painted Hours is no exception.

I fell in love with Tanveer and Elsie every bit as much as they fell in love with each other. Their story was beautiful, captivating and perfectly steeped in the trials and tribulations of a turbulent era. If you remember those big, sweeping historical sagas as fondly as I do, you’re absolutely going to fall in love with this book. I certainly did.

TLC

TLC tour schedule:

Monday, August 10th: IG: @fullybookedinkentucky

Monday, August 10th: IG: @a_book_read_in_jersey

Monday, August 10th: TT: @copperforestbookshop

Monday, August 10th: TT: @jess4reads

Monday, August 10th: Novels Alive – review

Monday, August 10th: IG: @diveintoagoodbook – review

Tuesday, August 11th: TT: @respecka

Tuesday, August 11th: IG: @bookapotamus

Tuesday, August 11th: TT: @juliannas_booktok

Tuesday, August 11th: IG: @jacklynsbooknook

Wednesday, August 12th: IG: @dianas_books_cars_coffee

Wednesday, August 12th: IG: @reecaspiecesbooks and TT: @reecaspiecesbooks – review

Thursday, August 13th: IG: @dana.loves.books and TT: @dana.loves.books5

Thursday, August 13th:  @enjoyingbooksagain – review

Thursday, August 13th: IG: @purrfectpages

Thursday, August 13th: TT: @dharashahauthor

Thursday, August 13th: IG: @thenightowlnook

Thursday, August 13th:  Laura’s Reviews and IG: @laurasreviews_1 – review

Friday, August 14th: IG: @poisedpen

Friday, August 14th: IG: @andrea.c.lowry.reads

Friday, August 14th: IG: @deannaturnsthepage and TT: @deannaturnsthepage

Friday, August 14th: View from the Birdhouse – review

Monday, August 17th: IG: @welovebigbooksandwecannotlie and TT: @welovebigbooks – review

Tuesday, August 18th: IG: @readingpastdark.marcia

Tuesday, August 18th: Reading Reality – review

Wednesday, August 19th: The Bookish Dilettante – review

Wednesday, August 19th: IG: @reading.late.into.the.night

Wednesday, August 19th: IG: @bookbenderwitch

Wednesday, August 19th: IG: @webreakforbooks

Wednesday, August 19th: TT: @zaineylaney

Thursday, August 20th: IG: @angiearoundwonderland

Thursday, August 20th: TT: @readerinthestorm

Friday, August 21st: Helen’s Book Blog – review

Friday, August 21st: IG: @smashley.reads and TT: @smashley.reads

Saturday, August 22nd:  IG: @booksandcoffeemx

Monday, August 24th: IG: @iambibliomane

Monday, August 24th: IG: @the.caffeinated.reader

Monday, August 24th: IG: @ifcatscouldread – review

Tuesday, August 25th: IG: @girlsinbooks

Tuesday, August 25th: IG: @lexijava

Wednesday, August 26th: IG: @meghan_readsbooks

Wednesday, August 26th: @books_old_and_new – review

Wednesday, August 26th: Cerebral Girl in a Redneck World – review

Thursday, August 27th: IG: @lifeofabookqueen

Thursday, August 27th: IG: @cmtloveswineandbooks

Thursday, August 27th: IG: @bookedbychristina – review

Friday, August 28th: IG: @booksloveandunderstanding

Friday, August 28th: IG: @oilycaffeinatedmama

Saturday, August 29th: IG: @subakka.bookstuff

Monday, August 31st: Eliot’s Eats – review

Monday, August 31st: IG: @reader_ceygo

Monday, August 31st: IG: @that.bookmom

Tuesday, September 1st: IG: @aurorabookreading

Wednesday, September 2nd: IG: @edensbookden

Wednesday, September 2nd: IG: @reading.with.mama.kenna

Wednesday, September 2nd: IG: @cam_leary – review

Thursday, September 3rd: Bibliotica

Thursday, September 3rd: IG: @just_another_mother_with_books

Thursday, September 3rd: IG: @spaceonthebookcase and TT: @spaceonthebookcase

Saturday, September 5th: Girl Who Reads – review

Sunday, September 6th: IG: @nissa_the.bookworm

#BookReview: The Wizard Who Kept Himself Suspicious by Scott Lynch

#BookReview: The Wizard Who Kept Himself Suspicious by Scott LynchThe Wizard Who Kept Himself Suspicious (Magic & Mystery, #5) by Scott Lynch
Narrator: Joel Froomkin
Format: audiobook, ebook
Source: borrowed from Amazon Kindle Unlimited
Formats available: ebook, audiobook
Genres: fantasy, fantasy mystery
Series: Magic & Mystery #5
Pages: 52
Length: 1 hour and 31 minutes
Published by Amazon Original Stories on July 28, 2026
Purchasing Info: Author's WebsitePublisher's WebsiteAmazon
Goodreads

When egos clash during an assemblage of wizards, grandstanding displays of magic become a matter of murder in a witty and suspenseful short story by a New York Times bestselling author.
Curmudgeonly conjurer Shiverick joins a conclave of fellow wizards on the strangest beach in the world expecting the usual flashy outfits, hammy miracles, and predictable suspicions that his own powers are nil. After all, he’s never so much as cast a spell in public. When accusations of fraud end in a flamboyant murder, Shiverick must piece together the truth amid the chaos. An observant and logical thinker, it’s his time to shine.
Scott Lynch’s The Wizard Who Kept Himself Suspicious is part of the Magic & Mystery collection, puzzle-box mysteries from top fantasy authors. They can be read or listened to in one enchanting sitting.

My Review:

Every time I looked at the title of this entry in the Magic & Mystery collection it gave me a bit of a pause. It felt like there was a piece missing, or words in the wrong order, or just something that niggled.

It wasn’t until my second time through (these are short and sometimes that’s just what you need for a reading pick-me-up) that I realized that the title has two meanings. From Shiverick’s own perspective – and it’s his perspective through which we experience the story – he keeps himself suspicious of his wizardly colleagues and the world he has lived in for the past six centuries. (At least six centuries.) It’s because he remains a bit suspicious of everyone and everything that he’s able to solve this murder.

Putting it another way, his innate suspiciousness keeps him from falling into the dangerous and deadly trap of “assume”.

At the same time, Shiverick keeps himself to himself and holds his many, many secrets so close to the chest of his always black robes that his colleagues remain a bit suspicious of him. Up to and including a suspicion that he’s not really a wizard because they’ve never seen him perform any actual magic. (In his world there are other methods of extending one’s life span than wizardly, making his extremely long life evidence of something but not necessarily of something he’s done rather than something he might have taken or stolen.)

From the reader’s perspective as Shiverick solves the murder, it’s likely that his magic is the magic of knowledge – particularly the knowledge of human nature. Possibly, it’s magic of the Sherlockian variety. Or it’s “merely” the magic of common sense, which is not nearly as common as it should be in either Shiverick’s world or our own.

Whatever the state of Shiverick’s magic, or the lack thereof, might be, it’s still a lot of fun to watch him work his own peculiar form of  it while successfully fending off yet another attempt on the part of his colleagues to force him to reveal more of his secrets than they have a right to know.

Escape Rating B: I listened to this one first, and then read it second. Fortunately it’s short. Having experienced both, I have to recommend the text over the audio. STRONGLY. If I’d relied on just the audio, this would have been a C instead of a B.

All of the wizards in this tredecennial (once every thirteen years) conclave all have huge, over-the-top personalities. (They’d probably fit right in with the wizards at Unseen University in the Discworld.) They’re loud, they’re big, they’re bright (visually, at least), they’re showy. (They’re probably also FINE in the sense of FINE as an acronym for “fucked-up, insecure, neurotic and egotistical” but that’s another universe.)

In the audiobook, the narrator has given each of them an individual, idiosyncratic, over the top accent. The reading isn’t so much a narration as it is a case of too much of a good thing being very much not wonderful. Listening to the STORY got lost in doing my damndest to understand what each character was saying. Even Shiverick.

The text is written from Shiverick’s wry, world-weary but ever observant perspective, and in that voice the story is clear and easy to follow. We may be as lost as the rest of the wizards in following his logic – because he’s way better at that than they are and there’s considerably more going on than we know at the outset – but the story and his thought processes are clear even if the way he reaches his conclusions is a bit convoluted. Then again, the murder plot was ALSO a bit convoluted, so that tracks.

I picked this one up relatively early in my reading/listening to this series because I loved the author’s Hugo-nominated novelette, “Kaiju Agonistes” and wanted to sample more of his work before diving into his Gentlemen Bastards series that begins with The Lies of Locke Lamora – which has been in my TBR pile for-pretty-much-ever at this point. After LISTENING to The Wizard Who Kept Himself Suspicious I started rethinking that idea, but after READING the story I’m re-thinking my re-thinking towards the positive again. Now I just need to catch the “round tuit” for the whole thing.

But in the meantime, I’ll be back with another novella in the Magic & Mystery collection in the next week or two, because I’m still loving it. Sometimes in audio, sometimes in text, but enjoying these short fantasy mysteries one way or another all the same.

#AudioBookReview: An Artful Dodge by Karen Odden

#AudioBookReview: An Artful Dodge by Karen OddenAn Artful Dodge by Karen Odden
Narrator: Anna Burnett
Format: audiobook, eARC
Source: supplied by publisher via Edelweiss, supplied by publisher via Libro.fm
Formats available: hardcover, ebook, audiobook
Genres: historical fiction, historical mystery
Pages: 368
Length: 11 hours and 25 minutes
Published by Recorded Books, Soho Crime on June 2, 2026
Purchasing Info: Author's WebsitePublisher's WebsiteAmazonBarnes & NobleKoboBookshop.orgBetter World Books
Goodreads

Victorian London comes to vivid life in this riveting heist novel about an all-female thieving gang and one young woman’s heroic plan to escape a life of crime.
She’s stolen gems, purses, and hearts—but can she steal her life back from the ring of thieves that’s claimed it?
London, 1879: Twenty-year-old Kit Jimeson has fingers so nimble she can nick a necklace off a lady in a crowded theater without raising alarm. Kit and her dodge partner, Mary, are the highest earners in the notorious all-women thieving ring in South London’s Elephant and Castle district.
Kit, whose mother had been a thief before her, dreams of a different life, one where she’s not constantly on the lookout for constables and plainclothes detectives, and where a mistake or pure bad luck won’t land her in the hangman’s noose. She has been saving her earnings so her younger sister, a maid for a wealthy Mayfair family, might have a shot at respectability.
Kit is very close to leaving the life entirely when the legendary former thief Maggie O’Connell brings her plans to a halt. Beautiful, charismatic Maggie has returned to reclaim leadership of the ring after twenty years in a brutal Australian penal colony. But Maggie desires more than mere wealth or power: She longs for revenge against those who sent her away. Kit, with her quick mind and dangerously clever hands, is Maggie’s best weapon. If Kit wants to walk away with her life, she must carry out a heist that will demand every skill she possesses.

My Review:

I’ll admit, I kind of expected this to be a play on Charles Dickens’ Oliver Twist because of the title. The “Artful Dodger” was a member of the thieving gang led by Fagin in the Victorian classic. It’s difficult not to think of Oliver while reading An Artful Dodge, as the Dodger was trying to recruit Oliver into the same kind of thieving ring that Kit Jimeson has been a member of for years.

But “The Ring” that Kit is such an integral part of is based on the real-life Forty Elephants, all-female thieving ring, which happened later in the Victorian era. Unlike Fagin’s gang of little pickpockets, “The Ring” relies on slightly more mature thieves. Kit wasn’t allowed to join the Ring until she was fourteen, and she’s been doing her best in the six years since to keep her younger sister Sarah as far out of it as possible.

One of the strengths of the story is that, in its deep immersion in its time and place, it doesn’t make moral judgments about the existence of the Ring or its necessity in allowing Kit and her fellow thieves to survive in a world that has few legitimate places for young women on their own. The Ring isn’t so much a choice as it is a chance for survival that is never exactly safe but is safer than being on her own after the loss of both her parents.

The Ring provides safe rooms, meals and even education. In return Kit thieves from shops catering to the gentry. Whether the shopkeepers can afford it or not isn’t the question. The question is whether they can afford it better than she can and the answer is always yes. It’s about survival, which means making a living wage at a time and place when other options were almost non-existent.

We see this world through Kit’s eyes at a time of change. Scotland Yard is taking property crimes like theft a lot more seriously than they used to – and they’re getting better at catching the thieves. Transportation to the Australian penal colonies is no longer an option, so thieves are either imprisoned or hung instead of ‘merely’ (definitely scare quotes there) transported.

Kit’s personal security is imperiled when the leader of the Ring who has been mentoring her for years is forced to step down by the daughter of the previous leader, just returned after 20 years of that transportation. Kit senses that something about the transfer isn’t right, she knows she can’t trust this new leader who came in with an old grudge against her, and her sister is in danger after witnessing a murder.

Kit’s world is closing in and there’s danger all around, even as she realizes that her oldest, deepest friendship has taken a turn towards romance she’s not certain she’s either able or ready to accept.

Which is where betrayal enters the scene, and things turn darkest. To protect everyone she loves, she’ll have to use every skill she has to escape the trap that her mother’s sins have dragged her into. Not knowing that someone else has planned better and further ahead.

Escape Rating B: I picked this up for two reasons. First, I really enjoyed both of the author’s historical mystery series, Victorian Mystery (A Dangerous Duet and A Trace of Deceit) and Inspector Corravan (Down a Dark River and Under a Veiled Moon). Second, my reading group LOVED An Artful Dodge and I hoped to do the same.

I did like it, but I didn’t love it the way I expected to. And part of that liking was certainly Anna Burnett’s excellent narration. But I’ve been trying to figure out why it didn’t grab me the way I thought it would ever since I finished.

Coincidentally, I was reading Heart of the Nile by Will Thomas as I was listening to An Artful Dodge. Both stories are set in the Victorian Era, although Thomas’ Barker and Llewelyn series is set nearly two decades after An Artful Dodge. Both stories are told in the first-person, Nile by private enquiry agent Thomas Llewelyn and Dodge by thief Kit Jimeson.

So we’re inside both of their heads and see their respective adventures through their eyes. But Heart of the Nile had me on the edge of my seat from the off, while An Artful Dodge, although it immersed me in its time and place every bit as much as Heart of the Nile, didn’t grab my attention and keep it as firmly in its grasp.

I’ve been pondering that difference for literally DAYS. I think the answer is that, although we see the world through their eyes and feel their emotions from inside, the pacing of An Artful Dodge is more than a bit slower. You’d think it wouldn’t be, as Kit is part of a thieving gang, danger is just as real and imminent for her – if not more so – than it is for Llewelyn, and there’s clearly betrayal on every single side.

But Kit describes every single thing and every person in exhaustive detail – as well as her own detailed thoughts and feelings about all of it. She worries, she ruminates, she mulls, she angsts. She doesn’t exactly repeat herself, but we get every detail of all of it, or so it seems. The story does a great job of describing her world in a great deal of detail, but the pacing drove me mad.

Llewelyn, on the other hand, definitely is not a stone or a stoic. He feels his feelings, he worries the case is putting his wife in danger, his boss drives half-insane, he spends a morning in jail on a point of his boss’s principle. He gets shot at more than once. But he doesn’t wring those emotions to death. And we still get the sense of time and place – enough but not TOO much, while he gets on with telling the story.

The idea of this book is fascinating, based a bit on the slightly later, but entirely real, Forty Elephants, a historical female thieving gang operating in the same Elephant and Castle area led by Alice Diamond. So fascinating, in fact, that there are two fictionalizations of Alice’s story in The Forty Elephants and Queen of Thieves, as well as other books set in or near the same era about completely fictional female gangs like Alex Hay’s The Housekeepers. There’s clearly a LOT of fascinating stuff to be mined both on this topic and in this period and I really hope authors keep on mining it.

This particular book, however, gets a LOT of points for the immersion factor. There’s a whole lot about the living and working conditions of the era, particularly for women but just the lack of opportunity for everyone in what were referred to as “the lower classes”. That information is wonderfully conveyed through the story without the story being in service to the lesson.

And I did like Kit as a character and rooted her to come out of this mess with a whole skin and a happy ending. I even empathized with how much she worried and ruminated, because there was a lot happening to her and around her, a lot of it was dangerous for her, her sister, the gang, and everyone she knew, and there were plenty of opportunities for dramatic tension.

But for this reader, that tension got muted by the slow pace of the story. As I already know that reading mileage varies on this one, for the legions of readers who enjoy stories that include in depth descriptions and perceptions, Kit’s ‘artful dodge’ of pretending to herself that everything will be fine when in her heart of hearts she half scared out of her mind – and with good reason – will undoubtedly keep those readers enthralled from beginning to end.

A- #AudioBookReview: Miss Gentle and the Case of the Very Flat Monk by Travis Baldree

A- #AudioBookReview: Miss Gentle and the Case of the Very Flat Monk by Travis BaldreeMiss Gentle and the Case of the Very Flat Monk (Magic & Mystery, #1) by Travis Baldree
Narrator: Travis Baldree
Format: audiobook, ebook
Source: borrowed from Amazon Kindle Unlimited
Formats available: ebook, audiobook
Genres: cozy fantasy, fantasy, fantasy mystery
Series: Magic & Mystery #1
Pages: 33
Length: 43 minutes
Published by Amazon Original Stories on July 28, 2026
Purchasing Info: Author's WebsitePublisher's WebsiteAmazon
Goodreads

A peculiar detective takes on a monastic murder mystery in a darkly funny fantasy short story by the #1 New York Times bestselling author of the Legends & Lattes series.
Nobody really liked Brother Gorm, but his untimely and abrupt descent from the abbey’s bell tower has the Order of Venerous the Petulant on edge. Desperate to settle the case before the bishop returns, the abbot enlists the highly unorthodox investigator Miss Gentle. As she clanks through the abbey in a full suit of armor, the cantankerous detective has no problem asking awkward questions—but will she get any answers?
Travis Baldree’s Miss Gentle and the Case of the Very Flat Monk is part of the Magic & Mystery collection, puzzle-box mysteries from top fantasy authors. They can be read or listened to in one enchanting sitting.

My Review:

This is technically the first story in the Magic & Mystery  collection, but I couldn’t resist reading/listening to The Lion’s Tusk first because I had to find out what that title was about. AND I wanted a visit with Ana and Din.

Curiosity about parts that no lion should possess aside, this is otherwise an excellent story to open this fantasy mystery series because it has plenty of both. Along with a heaping helping of the cozy fantasy vibe that the author is famous for. (Not that this story is set in the world of Legends & Lattes – as far as we know – but it feels like it could have been.)

The beginning is a classic. Brother Gorm was dead, to begin with. He was also more than a bit gormless in the classic sense, having been stupid, slow-witted, and lacking common sense. In this particular case also friendless, hapless, hopeless and clumsy as an ox.

It’s not actually a surprise that Brother Gorm is dead. The surprise is that in spite of his terrible personality, it doesn’t seem as if anyone actually did him in. Even if he did fall from the top of a parapet that it should have been impossible to fall from without a bit of ‘help’. Help that there’s no evidence whatsoever that he had.

Which is where Miss Gentle comes into the picture. She sounds like an irascible little old lady. She looks like an armored knight festooned with holy relics. She’s purported to be the best detective in the world. All she wants in return for solving the abbey’s little mystery and giving the remaining brethren back their piece of mind is yet another relic to add to her collection.

Not money, not gems, not any ‘worldly’ goods, but one, particular relic, The abbey’s – or at least the abbot’s – pride and joy, the priceless Tongue of Saint Caddlemore. Well, it was priceless. Now it’s the price of a solution to the mystery, and the answer to the question of whether or not the late Brother Gorm(less) can be buried in consecrated ground. Or something like that.

Miss Gentle leads the Abbot – and the entire abbey – on a merry chase in pursuit of the solution. It’s only after she’s left with her prize that the reader learns the rest of the story. And it’s a doozy.

Escape Rating A-: I listened to this one, and it’s read by the author. In fact, it’s read EXCELLENTLY by the author. If you can get any of his work in audio, he’s just right to read his stories, as rare as that is. And believe me, it is.

This story is just plain fun. We know Miss Gentle has a secret hidden inside her armor. It’s hard not to guess THAT much. But the nature of her secret wasn’t quite what I thought it was. In the end, little of this story was what I thought it was, in ways that reminded me a bit of Lois McMaster Bujold’s Penric and Desdemona series. Because it turns out this is also a world where the gods are real and do real things in the world.

In the case of this particular god, Venerous the Petulant, it turns out that he loved cats. Unfortunately for Brother Gorm, he truly was gormless. Not only did he not love cats himself, but he served a god that did. Very much, in fact. And was too slow-witted not to visit his own dislike of the abbey’s resident mouser upon said mouser’s person at every opportunity.

The cat was bound to get back at him, sooner or later. And their god was bound to help the cat and not the monk.

And Miss Gentle was bound to figure it all out. Not because she’s a great detective, but because she has a great secret. A secret that will keep her tramping about the countryside searching for relics as long as her magic – and her will – hold out.

This was just plain fun. At first, it’s a bit slow to get started and that’s deliberate. Miss Gentle is building up her schtick and it’s working on both the Abbot and the reader. He has to believe, we have to get caught up, and we both do. In the end, he decides he’s better off if he doesn’t know Miss Gentle’s truth as long as his problem is solved. Which it is. For the reader, the final reveal is a real belly laugh of a conclusion.

I’m definitely looking forward to reading/listening to the rest of the Magic & Mystery  collection, because so far it’s a hoot!

Grade A #AudioBookReview: The Lion’s Tusk by Robert Jackson Bennett

Grade A #AudioBookReview: The Lion’s Tusk by Robert Jackson BennettThe Lion’s Tusk (Shadow of the Leviathan) by Robert Jackson Bennett
Narrator: hannah curtis
Format: audiobook, ebook
Source: borrowed from Amazon Kindle Unlimited
Formats available: ebook, audiobook
Genres: epic fantasy, fantasy, fantasy mystery
Series: Shadow of the Leviathan, Magic & Mystery #3
Pages: 38
Length: 1 hour and 14 minutes
Published by Amazon Original Stories on July 28, 2026
Purchasing Info: Author's WebsitePublisher's WebsiteAmazon
Goodreads

An eccentric detective turns to the fantastical to solve a cold case in a short story by the Hugo Award–winning author of The Tainted Cup.

On a long carriage journey with her assistant Din, brilliant investigator Ana Dolabra ponders a solution to an impossible crime that has remained unsolved for centuries. A lavish wedding for two noble scions of the Empire descended into chaos when the newlyweds were found murdered in their marriage bed. But Ana—an expert in ancient myths, awakened beasts, and magic—knows that nothing is impossible, only unimaginable.

Robert Jackson Bennett’s The Lion’s Tusk is part of the Magic & Mystery collection, puzzle-box mysteries from top fantasy authors. They can be read or listened to in one enchanting sitting.

My Review:

Lions don’t HAVE tusks – not in our world. Not even in the world of the Shadow of the Leviathan series, where Ana Dolabra and her assistant Dinios Kol travel around the empire shoring up the foundations by solving mysteries and restoring a tiny bit of order, one case at a time.

Which should have been a clue to someone that something wasn’t quite what it purported to be. But “The Lion’s Tusk” was a legendary relic, making it the perfect wedding gift from a high-ranking church official to a rich reprobate that he hates and the despicable man’s unfortunate bride upon the occasion of their wedding.

Notice that no one in the above description is happy about the whole thing, to begin with. Which does explain why the brilliant and eccentric (extremely eccentric) investigator Ana Dolabra is intrigued with this particular case. (That’s it’s every bit as gut-wrenchingly gruesome as the first case she sends Din out on is all part of the “fun”. Or at least Ana’s fun, which is frequently gut-wrenching and gruesome all by itself.)

This particular case was never officially solved. It’s so historical that it’s not merely cold but ice cold, making it a perfect case for Ana to trot out for Din’s edification – and her own amusement – on a long, boring trip to one of the far-flung corners of the vast empire they serve.

The case, as Ana states at the beginning, is so old and so cold (in more ways than one) that there is no justice left to be had. Or the guilty have already been judged in a higher – or lower – court than would have been available to the Imperial Iudex of which Ana and Din are both officers.

Which doesn’t mean that Ana doesn’t think she’s solved it – because of course she believes she has. Whether her conclusions are the correct ones may be in the mind of the reader, but whether she’s right or not – although she most likely is because Ana Dolabra is ALWAYS right in the end – she’s sure she’s figured it out. And so is Din. While telling the tale – and frequently provoking Din with her usual outrageousness – keeps Ana from indulging in any of her usual, more destructive outlets for alleviating crushing boredom. For which Din seems rather grateful even if he has to hang his head out the window of the carriage a few times to keep from retching over her disgustingly detailed descriptions.

Din is fascinated in spite of himself. And the reader – or at least this reader – is utterly enthralled from beginning to end.

Escape Rating A: I loved this from the opening paragraph. Then again, I expected to. This is a bit of a side story in the author’s utterly marvelous, absolutely fantastic Shadow of the Leviathan series, following the investigations of Ana Dolabra and her assistant Din. The series begins with The Tainted Cup, winner of the 2025 Hugo Award for Best (SF or Fantasy) Novel. (It was also nominated for Best (Crime/Mystery) Novel in the 2025 Edgar Awards) The follow-up book, A Drop of Corruption, is one of the nominees for this year’s Hugo Award, and the third book, A Trade of Blood, is coming out next month. (I’ve already finished it and it’s just as awesome as the first two.)

In other words, I was in the mood for another trip with Ana and Din, and this was the right story at the right time, made even better by listening to the audiobook read by Hannah Curtis. The full length books in this series are all told from Din’s perspective, but this short story has just that bit extra because Ana Dolabra is the one telling the story, and Curtis does an excellent job portraying her character.

Part of what I love about Ana and Din as investigators is that they are very much a play on Holmes and Watson, although Ana has considerably more scope for her eccentricities, and Din is more inexperienced than he is unintelligent. (OTOH, neither is Watson in the original stories. Pardon me while I step down my soapbox.)

What I also love about this series is that it seems as if the author has single-handedly resurrected the entire fantasy mystery subgenre, and I’m definitely there for it. (I have very fond memories of the classic Lord Darcy series, which was a foundation of the last time fantasy mystery was popular. I digress.)

As this is a cold case, another part of the fun is that this is effectively an “armchair mystery” – even though that chair is moving through the countryside. For anyone who has ever read Josephine Tey’s classic armchair mystery, The Daughter of Time, the similarities add a bit of nostalgia to this story.

Even better, all around, as much fun as I had with this particular story, is that it’s not alone. I mean, it stands alone in the sense that it’s not attached to any of the earlier stories in its series, although it helps if one is at least a bit familiar with the first book.

The Lion’s Tusk is also a part of another series, Amazon Original Stories Magic & Mystery series. The short stories in the collection are fantasy mysteries, they promise to be fascinating treats, and I can’t wait to read/listen to them ALL!

#AudioBookReview: Matcha on Monday by Michiko Aoyama translated by E. Madison Shimoda

#AudioBookReview: Matcha on Monday by Michiko Aoyama translated by E. Madison ShimodaMatcha on Monday (Marble Cafe, #2) by Michiko Aoyama
Translator: E. Madison Shimoda
Narrator: Ami Okumura Jones, Daniel Bunton, Sadao Udea, Winson Ting
Format: audiobook, eARC
Source: supplied by publisher via Edelweiss, supplied by publisher via Libro.fm
Formats available: hardcover, ebook, audiobook
Genres: healing fiction, relationship fiction, translated fiction, world literature
Series: Marble Cafe #2
Pages: 208
Length: 4 hours and 25 minutes
Published by Hanover Square Press, Harlequin Audio on July 7, 2026
Purchasing Info: Author's WebsitePublisher's WebsiteAmazonBarnes & NobleKoboBookshop.orgBetter World Books
Goodreads

Discover the beloved early classic from the million-copy bestselling author of WHAT YOU ARE LOOKING FOR IS IN THE LIBRARY
Across a bridge in a quiet neighborhood in Tokyo, a charming little matcha café – open only on Mondays – offers a beacon of light and healing to all who pass through its doors.

All throughout the week, customers flock to the Marble Café that’s tucked away behind the trees – except when it’s closed on Mondays, when the Matcha Café opens in its place, offering its clientele a warm cup of matcha and restoration to start the busy week ahead.On this one day of the week, people from all walks of life frequent this cozy haven and experience the joys of human connection. Among them include: • A singer who has just broken up with his lover • An unsociable young owner of a tea wholesaler • A husband who has made his wife angry • A designer and owner of a lingerie shop • A Kamishibai artist who doesn't get along with his grandmother
This heart-warming story spans Tokyo and Kyoto over twelve months, bringing together a community of untold unfolding lives – all starting with a cup of matcha.

My Review:

Tokyo’s Marble Cafe, the center of the interconnected stories in Hot Chocolate on Thursday, is never open on Mondays. At least, not unless the cafe’s owner, the Maestro, decides to hold a special event. Special events are always scheduled on Mondays, when the Marble Cafe is officially NOT the Marble Cafe.

On one particular Monday in January, the Maestro decides to open a Matcha Cafe. He’s helping out the son of an old colleague, by providing the young man a preview of what his life might be like opening a branch of his family’s traditional matcha cafe in Tokyo, where matcha isn’t currently as popular as it is in Kyoto, where the family business is based.

The young man is reluctant to make such a drastic change in his life for any number of reasons, none of which the readers are aware of. And neither is the young woman who enters the cafe looking for a treat on a day that definitely needs one. At least from her own perspective. She has no clue that she might be the treat FOR the man behind the counter making her matcha while awkwardly attempting small talk. Something he KNOWS he’s really bad at.

Like the first book in this series, Hot Chocolate on Thursday (when the Marble Cafe definitely IS open), the stories in this second book represent hands clasped around a circle. Also, this time around, the circle of an entire year.

That image, of people holding hands out one to another, is part of the Maestro’s own philosophy about life and connections. It’s a version of paying it forward, that everyone is connected to everyone else, and that people need to give thanks to the folks who created the connections that have led them to happiness and to do the same for others.

In the case of this particular round of stories, it begins with that young woman who is having a bad day after showing up for work on her day off. From there the story goes around the circle to a man returning to the cafe hoping for matcha in February, only to discover a better present nearby at a local lingerie shop. Which leads to a gift of lingerie that is not going to be worn at a wedding in March, to the beginnings of a resolution surrounding a long-standing contention between a young woman and her judgmental grandmother, and so on.

Each story is delightful in itself – and in the way that it seamlessly leads to the next. A couple of the stories provide a bit of an update on some of the characters involved in that first book, and of course it all comes full circle, as that cup of Hot Chocolate on Thursday did, to the couple who met but did not manage to connect – yet – over that Matcha on Monday. Except that the story in December is told from the opposite point of view.

But they’re all interconnected. Even if one of the characters never does manage fulfill their dream of shaking the hand of a kangaroo along the way.

Escape Rating B: This series, and stories like it, are definitely mood reads for me. Or mood listens, as this case turned out to be.I got hooked on these interconnected short stories after reading Before the Coffee Gets Cold, and it seems like the popularity of that book in the US opened the floodgates to making translations of other, similar series available.

Most of these stories are gentle reads. By gentle I mean that not a lot happens, there are no chase scenes or murders or grand passions. They’re stories about everyday life among everyday people, vignettes of mostly good things with the occasional bit of sad fluff thrown in to keep the whole thing from being too sweet.

The story about the contentious relationship between the young woman and her judgmental grandmother is the drop of bittersweetness in this particular cup. They do find a way forward, but old, bad habits prove VERY hard to break.

In the case of this particular book, and this particular series, I enjoy the way that the stories connect from one to another. It’s not subtle and it’s not intended to be and that’s just right. The way that the story comes full circle provides just the right amount of closure.

These are terrific stories to listen to at bedtime, enjoyable but not overly dramatic. And they’re great if you’re looking for something to lift your mood, just as the young woman is looking for a treat to lift hers in the first story.

I did listen to this one, as I did the previous book. And again, there are four narrators to keep the stories from sounding the same. While I’m not going to insert my usual rant about the lack of inclusion of a cast list in this multi-voiced production, that may be for the best in this particular case as there’s one story that is told from the perspective of a child, and the adult voice narrating that particular story was jarring to my ear. Not that the narrator didn’t do well in other parts of the book, but they sounded too obviously adult to be the right narrator in that one instance.

The next time I need another sweet reading/listening pick-me-up, I’m sure I’ll pick up another one of these stories. If you’re looking for something similar, please check out some of my favorites in this genre, including What You Are Looking For Is In the Library, The Kamogawa Food Detectives, The Ex-Boyfriend’s Favorite Recipe Funeral Committee, We’ll Prescribe You a Cat, and, of course, Hot Chocolate on Thursday.

#AudioBookReview: Cinder House by Freya Marske

#AudioBookReview: Cinder House by Freya MarskeCinder House by Freya Marske
Narrator: Anna Burnett
Format: audiobook, eARC
Source: supplied by publisher via Edelweiss, supplied by publisher via Libro.fm
Formats available: hardcover, ebook, audiobook
Genres: fairy tales, fantasy, fantasy romance
Pages: 144
Length: 4 hours and 34 minutes
Published by Macmillan Audio, Tordotcom on October 7, 2025
Purchasing Info: Author's WebsitePublisher's WebsiteAmazonBarnes & NobleKoboBookshop.orgBetter World Books
Goodreads

Sparks fly and lovers dance in this gorgeous, yearning Cinderella retelling from bestselling author Freya Marske—a queer Gothic romance perfect for fans of Naomi Novik and T. Kingfisher.
Ella is a haunting.
Murdered at sixteen, her ghost is furiously trapped in her father's house, invisible to everyone except her stepmother and stepsisters.
Even when she discovers how to untether herself from her prison, there are limits. She cannot be seen or heard by the living people who surround her. Her family must never learn she is able to leave. And at the stroke of every midnight, she finds herself back on the staircase where she died.
Until she forges a wary friendship with a fairy charm-seller, and makes a bargain for three nights of almost-living freedom. Freedom that means she can finally be seen. Danced with. Touched.
You think you know Ella's story: the ball, the magical shoes, the handsome prince.
You're halfway right, and all-the-way wrong.
Rediscover a classic fairy tale in this debut novella from "the queen of romantic fantasy" (Polygon).
At the Publisher's request, this title is being sold without Digital Rights Management Software (DRM) applied.

My Review:

Just as the blurb says, you think you know this story. If you’ve ever read Marissa Meyer’s Cinder, or Alix E. Harrow’s Fractured Fables duology (A Spindle Splintered and A Mirror Mended) you may think you have a handle on all the variations on this story as well.

We’ve all grown up on it, after all, thanks to Disney. The wicked stepsisters, the drudge who wants to go to the ball, the fairy godmother (or mothers), the prince, the shoes. And all those elements are here in Cinder House.

And so is Ella. Or, at least, in this case, the ghost of Ella, trapped in the house where she was murdered, still serving as the drudge of all work for her murderous stepmother and her stepsisters, one evil and one just as trapped in her own way as Ella is in hers.

Ella’s stepmother may be the one who killed her, but it’s the house itself that has trapped her. Because the house is sentient. It can’t speak, not exactly, but it still needs a way to express its grief and its anger, and it needs a vessel to hold its grudges. Ella is its hands, its voice, and its only possibility for revenge.

All it has to do is watch and wait and let Ella’s suffering fester within its walls, driving her towards revenge for them both. Unless, with the help of a literal fairy godmother, Ella can find a way out from under both her family and her family’s house that no one ever imagined.

UK cover because its pretty AND pretty descriptive at the same time!

Escape Rating B+: I picked this up because this was the only novella among this year’s Hugo nominees that I hadn’t read. I remember checking it out multiple times and then skipping over it, probably because I did think I knew the story. In the end, well, I LOVED the end. That was perfect. And all the stuff about Ella being a ghost and the way that worked was a new and different way of handling Ella’s situation and just the way that ghostliness worked overall was well done.

I think my mixed feelings are in just how much of the early part of the story was taken up in detailing, not Ella’s ghostly situation because that was fascinating, but her continuing abuse at the hands of one of her stepsisters who was both a sorceress AND a psychopath. Not that all of that didn’t need to be established, not that it wasn’t important to the story, but there was a lot of “oh woe is me” that was just more than I wanted no matter how justified it was. And it was.

How Ella’s ghostliness worked was fascinating, and new and different. But her stepsisters’ treatment of her was old and sad and a bit overdone for my personal taste. As is often the case for me, when I listen to a book, as I did with Cinder House, when the narrator is good, as Anna Burnett certainly was, I find myself feeling a bit too much for the character’s personal travails because I’m too much inside their head. Which makes the listening experience simultaneously excellent and uncomfortable.

Howsomever, as I said, the ending of this was terrific AND terrifically unexpected in the way that it worked out. And not just because a happy ending in a romance between a ghost and a living human is a bit of a puzzle to arrange. The unconventionality of the arrangement between the Prince, his political bride, his ghost and her two best friends was a surprise and a delight. I wasn’t expecting the way it worked out AT ALL but I was very happy that it did – if not quite as happy as they were!

#AudioBookReview: The Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts by Robert Thorogood

#AudioBookReview: The Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts by Robert ThorogoodThe Mysterious Affair of Judith Potts (The Marlow Murder Club Book 5) by Robert Thorogood
Narrator: Nicolette McKenzie
Format: audiobook, eARC
Source: supplied by publisher via Edelweiss, supplied by RB Media
Formats available: hardcover, paperback, ebook, audiobook
Genres: cozy mystery, mystery
Series: Marlow Murder Club #5
Pages: 256
Length: 8 hours and 49 minutes
Published by Poisoned Pen Press, Recorded Books on January 15, 2026
Purchasing Info: Author's WebsitePublisher's WebsiteAmazonBarnes & NobleKoboBookshop.orgBetter World Books
Goodreads

The new cozy crime novel from the bestselling author of The Marlow Murder Club, now a major TV series on PBS Masterpiece!
Two dead celebrities. One village full of secrets.
Someone is killing celebrities in Marlow. First, it's a famous soccer player. Then, a bestselling thriller writer. When two shocking deaths rock their quiet riverside town, Judith, Suzie, and Becks—the unstoppable Marlow Murder Club—must untangle a dangerous web of blackmail and scandal to catch a killer.
But with their trusted police ally DI Malik suddenly suspended, and Judith's own past threatening to resurface, the women are on their own. Suspects are multiplying like tabloid headlines, secrets are stacking up, and time is running out.
Can the Marlow Murder Club crack the case before the killer strikes again—or will this be the end of their crime-solving adventures?

My Review:

Judith Potts is off her game in this fifth entry in the Marlow Murder Club series. A young woman has barged into Judith’s life, utterly convinced that Judith murdered her father three decades ago, and determined to hound and harass the older woman until she confesses to her crime.

That Eleni Paphides’ father was, at the time, Judith’s abusive, unfaithful husband – adds more than one layer of complication to the accusation, as Judith seems equally determined to keep her thoughts and memories shrouded, even from herself, AND keep her sleuthing friends Suzie and Becks out of her business.

The situation is already complicated enough when a fresh murder occurs, just as the three women should be celebrating the triumphant solution to their previous case (Murder on the Marlow Belle).

Someone has shot and killed a popular local footballer (read as soccer player on this side of the pond) while internal politicking at the local police department has taken their friend , Detective Inspector Tamika Malik, off the case and quite possibly out of a job. This time around, the members of the Marlow Murder Club are on their own, with Tamika’s replacement determined to keep them off the case, even as the bodies start piling up among Marlow’s rich and famous.

Without Tamika helping them from the inside with access and especially information, the Murder Club is operating a bit out of their depth. Combined with Judith’s increasing distraction – and eventual outright disappearance – Suzie and Becks are on their own solving the murders.

That all of these complications have the same spider at the center of their web is a connection that even the reader doesn’t see coming until the very last minute. When Judith, with the help of her friends, finally lures him into a web of their own.

Escape Rating B: I read the first book in this series, liked it more than well enough to pick up the following books, but just didn’t catch the ‘round tuit’ until I was offered an audiobook for this latest entry and thought this looked like the perfect time for another visit.

And so it proved. The audio was terrific, and Nicolette McKenzie did a terrific job with all of the voices. She did a particularly good job of making the voices of Judith, Suzie and Becks distinct from one another, so there was no question who was speaking even when, technically, only one person was speaking. (Ahem. So to speak.)

The story is the kind of twisty mystery that one expects from these cozy but deadly series. On the one hand, Marlow’s murder rate is more than a bit high for such a small place. OTOH, familiarity breeds contempt and the residents of a small town like Marlow have more than enough time to build up plenty of contempt for each other. The fun in these murder club series is the way that the club members manage to already know more of everyone else’s business that should be comfortable – and that no one outright murders them for sticking their noses into the rest.

Although an attempt certainly gets made in this convoluted mystery. It’s more of a surprise that that hasn’t happened sooner. Or more often. Or both.

The mystery that Judith Potts has seemingly been running away from for three decades is actually a lot more interesting than the murders – because it forces all three women to face their doubts about each other and the moral quandaries that surround their dangerous hobby.

Judith might have murdered her husband and gotten away with it. Her teases and hints and willfully occluded memories certainly add to that possibility. It’s clear she’s not exactly innocent, although it’s a question to what degree she’s actually guilty. Whatever degree of guilt she has, Suzie and Becks need to decide what they believe, what they believe might be justified, and what their consciences require them to do about whatever they eventually discover about their friend.

The resolution of the actual murder case does manage to restore order to Marlow – or at least as much order as this murder capital ever manages to contain. But the revelations about Judith’s past – and her friends’ reactions in the present – are certainly going to be a factor in future books in the series – which I’m now looking forward to. Because this story can’t possibly be the end of Judith’s, Suzie’s and Becks’ adventures in crime solving.

When I read the first book in this series, the titular Marlow Murder Club, I thought at the time that Judith Potts reminded me every bit as much of Maud, the octogenarian serial killer in An Elderly Lady is up to No Good as she did retired MI6 operative Elizabeth Best from The Thursday Murder Club. Something that feels even more true after finishing this book than it did after reading the first!

But while I’m waiting for that sixth book, I’ll go back to see what I missed in those middle stories, Death Comes to Marlow, The Queen of Poisons and Murder on the Marlow Belle. It was clear in THIS story that I did miss some things. Not enough to keep me from enjoying this book, but enough to be a tease to make me go back and find out.

#AudioBookReview: Our Perfect Storm by Carley Fortune

#AudioBookReview: Our Perfect Storm by Carley FortuneOur Perfect Storm by Carley Fortune
Narrator: AJ Bridel, Jack Copeland
Format: audiobook, eARC
Source: supplied by publisher via Edelweiss, supplied by publisher via Libro.fm
Formats available: hardcover, ebook, audiobook
Genres: contemporary romance, friends to lovers romance
Pages: 410
Length: 10 hours and 51 minutes
Published by Berkley, Penguin Audio on May 5, 2026
Purchasing Info: Author's WebsitePublisher's WebsiteAmazonBarnes & NobleKoboBookshop.orgBetter World Books
Goodreads

Best friends have one week in paradise to fix their friendship or fall apart in this heart-stopping, utterly romantic new novel from the #1 New York Times bestselling author of Every Summer After and One Golden Summer.
Frankie and George have been best friends since they were eight years old. Both passionate, impulsive, and headstrong—they’ve always clashed . . . and come back together. Until now. It’s the eve of Frankie’s wedding weekend, and she doesn’t know where they stand or even if George will show up as her best man.
Then, at the start of the festivities, in walks George. For one glorious evening, surrounded by her loved ones, Frankie’s life is finally perfect. But it all comes crashing down when her fiancé dumps her the next morning, leaving only a note as an explanation.
Crushed and confused, Frankie returns to her family’s home to wallow. But George has a different idea and a plan for healing Frankie’s broken heart. He wants her to go on her honeymoon. With him. For one week, to the lush rainforests and misty beaches of Tofino.
Frankie agrees, seeing the trip for what it really is: one last chance to repair their friendship. Even if it means unearthing secrets and long buried feelings neither knows how to handle. Even if it means falling apart for good.

My Review:

The idea of this story is terrific. The execution didn’t quite work for me as well as I’d hoped. Although I can’t say this enough, the audio narration was terrific and made a story that didn’t live up to its potential worth listening to all the same.

This is a friends-to-lovers story. In fact, it’s about the lifelong friendship between Frankie and George. They’ve been besties since they were EIGHT. Most people are lucky if they can hang onto one friendship half that long, but Frankie and George are thirty when this story begins and in some ways are every bit as close as they were when George moved in next door over twenty years ago.

And in other ways they are miles apart. Mostly in secrets. The secret that George has been keeping from Frankie since they were 14, if not earlier. And the secret that Frankie has been keeping from herself every single bit as long.

George is supposed to be Frankie’s best man at her wedding to someone else. She’s a nervous wreck at her own rehearsal dinner because she can’t imagine doing this – or anything else important in her life – without George at her side. George is coming because he promised he would be there for her. Even if she’s breaking his heart. Because she doesn’t know that she is and he’s not planning to tell her. EVER.

Whether he should have stuck to that plan or not is one thing. Whether he should have broken it quite so thoroughly is another. Whether they can get past the mess they both make out of the result is yet to be determined.

But they have to try. Even if Frankie doesn’t know exactly what they’re trying for. Or about. Or why it always had to be just this messy along the way.

Escape Rating B-: The storm may be perfect but this book isn’t nearly so. The audio was terrific, which is why I stuck with it to the point that I had to finish, but the story drove me bananas until the 2/3rds mark, and that’s way too long to be talking back to an audiobook.

The IDEA of this as a friends into lovers story had SO MUCH possibility. I liked Frankie and George as characters and loved the idea of their lifelong best friendship. BUT, I knew from the opening pages that Frankie was being willfully obtuse about her upcoming marriage to Nate and especially the nature of her adult relationship with George. Or at least his adult feelings for her.

It’s so, so obvious to the reader that George has been in love with Frankie for years – if not possibly forever – from the minute he enters the scene. At her rehearsal dinner for her wedding to someone else.

I started wanting to reach through the audio with a clue-by-four and didn’t stop until the penny dropped for her much, MUCH too late. Or too long. Healing takes as long as it takes, and people lie to themselves ALL THE TIME, but her obstinate, angsty blindness went on for too many words and too many pages.

In other words, the story dragged A LOT in the middle. If the audio performances by AJ Bridel as Frankie and Jack Copeland as George hadn’t been excellent, I’d have bailed early. But they WERE excellent and the way the audio was performed – not as alternate chapters but as Frankie’s narration of her perspective on events and her internal thoughts with George’s own voice in her head worked better than the now usual alternating chapters and voices.

This would be a C rating if not for the audio. They’re that good. And the story needs them to be.

In the end, I got why George hid his feelings from Frankie for so long – even if the way he went about the reveal was a bit shitty. The whole thing finally started to work when Frankie started figuring out that she’d been lying to herself for reasons that made a whole lot of sense – IN THE END.

But by the time I got to that end I was mostly sticking with it to see if my guesses about why her erstwhile groom bailed on the wedding the night before were correct. Which they were. In the end, this story turned out to be a combination of too much obviousness and too much obliviousness tied up with a tiny bow of obnoxiousness in one tantalizing package.

And by that I mean the descriptions of Tofino, which is a real place that I would love to visit – just not along with Frankie and George.